Viw Magazine

Business Coach

  • Written by Julian Teicher, Professor of Human Resources and Employment and Deputy Dean (Research), School of Business and Law, CQUniversity Australia
A man convicted of child pornography access and possession has won an employment discrimination case against Suncorp Pixabay

A man twice convicted of child pornography charges was discriminated against by an employer due to his offending past, the Australian Human Rights Commission has found.

The employment candidate, known as BE in the case proceedings, was convicted of accessing and possessing child pornography in 2008. He was further convicted of breaching a reporting requirement.

Insurance giant Suncorp revoked his employment offer, prompting BE to lodge a case with the Australian Human Rights Commission. The commission ruled in favour of BE, recommending Suncorp compensate him $2500.

The case has raised questions about the adequacy of Australia’s discrimination laws, and drawn criticism of the Australian Human Rights Commission.


Read more: For women fighting the gender pay gap discrimination law is limited


Employer Discrimination

BE applied for a job with Suncorp as a home-based consultant in 2015. He was qualified for the job, having worked in a similar role previously. BE successfully passed the first two stages of the Suncorp recruitment process, and received a conditional offer based on the outcome of a criminal records check.

In 2008, BE was convicted of accessing and storing child pornography on his computer. He was sentenced to 12 months in jail, which was suspended for two years with $20,000 in bonds and charity payments. He was again convicted of not complying with reporting obligations in 2015. Initially, BE did’t fully disclose the details of his conviction in his application form. He later elaborated during a telephone interview with recruiters.

Discrimination occurs when a distinction, exclusion, or preference restricts an employment opportunity when the inherent requirements of a job are met. Amtec Staffing/Flickr

After his employment offer was revoked, BE lodged a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission. Suncorp listed two reasons for its decision to revoke BE’s offer: first, that an internal candidate had been chosen. Second, that due to BE’s criminal conviction, he could not meet the inherent requirements of the job.

The case sparked debate on discrimination law and societal responsibilities to convicted offenders. While employers may not want to hire someone with a criminal record, this goes against the principle that a person who has been convicted and punished has paid their debt to society.

Australia’s workplace discrimination laws

Not hiring someone due to their criminal record isn’t illegal in Australia, except in the Northern Territory and Tasmania. In every state, situations exist where an employer is legally required to refuse employment based on criminal records, such as when working with children.

Australia has declared a criminal conviction as grounds for discrimination “for the purposes of” the 1986 Australian Human Rights Commission Act. In Section 3 (1), discrimination is defined as a “distinction, exclusion or preference” that restricts an employment opportunity, unless necessitated by the “ inherent requirements of the job”. Complaints of discrimination are investigated by the Australian Human Rights Commission.

This definition of discrimination is broader than other federal and state legislation, which explains why BE took his complaint to the commission.

BE had twice been convicted of charges relating to child pornography. Pixabay

Criminal conviction discrimination is not illegal under the act. The commission can resolve complaints by conciliation, or dispute resolution. When the commission finds discrimination has occurred and conciliation is not possible, the commission is required to lodge a report with the federal Attorney-General to be tabled in parliament.

Australian Human Rights Commission case findings

A resolution couldn’t be reached between BE and Suncorp, so a report was submitted to the Attorney-General. The report recommended BE receive $2500 for “hurt, humiliation and distress”. Suncorp was asked to revise its recruitment policies to conform with the comission’s guidelines, and train its recruitment staff on these guidelines.

Suncorp argued BE didn’t meet the inherent requirements of the position due to the role’s “additional requirements”. Suncorp requires employees to “actively demonstrate Suncorp values — Courage, Honesty, Respect, Caring, Trust”. They argued that by not fully disclosing his convictions in the initial application, BE didn’t demonstrate honesty. They also expressed concern for his trustworthiness and the risk of him working unsupervised with internet access.


Read more: Three charts on: disability discrimination in the workplace


Suncorp’s concerns were thrown out by Australian Human Rights Commission president Professor Rosalind Croucher. She found that BE met the “inherent requirments”, which were “essential features” of the job and not something “peripheral”, such as trust and honesty. Croucher’s legal reasoning has been overlooked by critics of this Australian Human Rights Comission’s decision.

Australian Human Rights Commission President Rosalind Croucher said Suncorp discriminated against BE for his prior convictions. Australian Human Rights Commission/Flickr

Criticism of the Australian Human Rights Commission

The Australian Human Rights Commission has come under attack for its decision by the media and politicians. Andrew Bolt has called the human rights commission “nuts”, while The Australian quoted former senator Eric Abetz saying “why the Human Rights Commission constantly feels the need to go in to bat for murderers and paedophiles really is baffling”.

Attorney-General Christian Porter also expressed criticism at the case, vowing to look into it. Porter said

A legal overhaul may be required to prevent … being told to hire people convicted of serious sex offences or face discrimination proceedings”.

It is rare for an independent statutory body to be subject to sustained criticism. It is concerning, as it has the potential to undermine the importance of independent statutory bodies.

Whether the government has plans to amend the Australian Human Rights Commission Act to broaden the grounds for permissible discrimination remains to be seen. The review should consider whether the “inherent requirements” provisions of the act impose too great a restriction on the hiring decisions of employers.

Lawmakers should also consider whether the extent of criminal conviction discrimination is sufficiently widespread to justify amending the law to better protect those who suffer this form of employment discrimination.

Julian Teicher does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors: Julian Teicher, Professor of Human Resources and Employment and Deputy Dean (Research), School of Business and Law, CQUniversity Australia

Read more http://theconversation.com/why-the-human-rights-commission-was-right-to-rule-employment-discrimination-in-child-pornography-conviction-case-99518

Important Instructions for Australians Living in Camper Trailers

Living in a camper trailer offers Australians a unique way to embrace adventure and freedom while exploring the vast and beautiful landsca...

Maintaining Your Mini Digger: Tips for Longevity and Performance

If you're a proud owner or operator of a mini digger in Australia, you understand the importance of keeping your equipment in top-notch co...

Transform Your Business To Success: The Role Of Branding Agencies In Melbourne

In the bustling city of Melbourne, where every corner tells a story of innovation and creativity, the importance of branding cannot be o...

Revealing The Timeless Appeal Of Ladies' Bodysuits

Fashion has always been a canvas for self-expression, a realm where innovation and tradition intertwine to create garments that not only a...

What Is Crude Oil, and Why Is It Important to Investors?

Crude oil is the lifeblood of the global economy. As an investor, understanding the ins and outs of this vital commodity can be crucial to...

A Sweet Tooth's Guide to the Best Cakes in Melbourne

Indulge your sweet tooth in Melbourne's finest cakes! Brunetti offers decadent chocolate delights like Ciambella Chocolate Teacakes. Mel...

Alan Williams' Impact on Chicago's Defense: Analyzing Key Changes and Improvements

When Alan Williams stepped onto the field as the defensive coordinator for Chicago, expectations were high. His reputation for crafting di...

Understanding the Different Types of Pickup Truck Car Covers

Picking the right truck cover starts with understanding the various types available on the market. Each type is designed to address specif...

Understanding Commercial Plumbing in Adelaide

Introduction In the bustling city of Adelaide, where businesses thrive across diverse sectors, the seamless operation of commercial facil...

Driving into the Future: The Evolution of the Automotive Market in Australia - Trends and Predictions

Examining “the evolution of the automotive market in Australia: trends and predictions” reveals a swift embrace of electric vehicles a...

Crocs: Defying Fashion Norms and Redefining Individuality

In the realm of contemporary footwear, a singular item has emerged as a polarizing yet undeniably iconic choice: the versatile rubber shoe...

Benefits of Network Monitoring Devices in Businesses

In an era where seamless connectivity underpins business operations, ensuring a robust and secure network is paramount for any enterprise...

Tips for Staying Socially Active as a Senior

Staying socially active as a senior can be a challenging task. It becomes particularly difficult as mobility decreases, and friends and fa...

The Benefits of Living in Nature

Have you ever dreamed of buying a mountain property for sale, living immersed in nature, and being surrounded by the beauty of trees and w...

Affordable and Chic: A Guide to Stylish Splashback Tiling on a Budget

When it comes to kitchen renovations, splashback tiling stands out as a game-changer. Not only does it serve a practical purpose by protec...

How to Choose the Perfect Trailer for Your Needs

Whether you're hauling equipment for work or embarking on a weekend adventure, selecting the right trailer is essential. With a myriad of ...

Is There a downside to Taking collagen peptides? Understanding the Side Effects for a Healthier You

Introduction  Lately, everyone seems to be talking about collagen peptides. They're a type of protein that comes from collagen, a key pa...

The Best Materials for Living Room Plantation Shutters: A Comparison

Plantation shutters are a timeless and elegant window treatment that adds both style and functionality to any living space. When it comes ...

Top 5 Home Renovations That Increase Property Value

Enhancing the value of your property is a common goal for homeowners, whether they plan to sell soon or simply want to boost their investm...

Discover the Elegance of Sheer Curtains in Melbourne: A Guide to Custom-Made Sheer Elegance

When it comes to enhancing the aesthetics and functionality of your living spaces, the right choice of window treatments can make all the ...

Tomorrow Business Growth