.

  • Written by Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University
There are words you'll need to understand. But imputation is complex, like the tax system. Wes Mountain/The Conversation, CC BY-ND

You’re forgiven for being confused.

Newspapers need to economise on words. Television and radio reporters need to economise on seconds. So they use shorthand: words like “dividend imputation”, “franking credits”, and yes, “retiree tax”

Which is fine if you already know what they mean, and pretty fine if you don’t, because you probably don’t need to. They speed things along.

Until now. Suddenly, because of their prominence in the upcoming election campaign, we are going to have to know what they mean. We are even going to have to know that one of them doesn’t mean what it seems to mean. The election might depend on it.

So here goes:

Taxable profits

If a company’s income exceeds its expenses, it has made a profit, which in ordinary circumstances is taxed at the leglislated rate, which for big companies such as Telstra and the big banks is 30 cents in the dollar.

Dividends

After the tax is taken out, companies can pay some of what’s left to shareholders as a dividend, one for each share.

Last September Telstra paid shareholders a dividend of 15.5 cents per share. The previous March it was 11 cents.

Income tax

Australians pay tax on what they earn, unless the income is classified as not taxable or is below the A$18,200 tax-free threshold. The marginal rate (the rate on extra income) climbs with income, so that anyone earning more than A$180,000 (the top threshold) pays 45 cents on each extra dollar earned.

Dividends are taxable and so are taxed along with other income.

Dividend imputation

In 1987 in what he hailed as a world first, Labor treasurer Paul Keating introduced a rebate for each each tax-paying dividend recipient.

Taken off their tax would be the company tax the company had paid on the part of the profit that had been handed to them as a dividend.

It “would greatly reduce the existing bias in the tax system which taxed interest income once, but dividend income twice”.

Here’s how it was to work at today’s tax rates.

  • Jill owns 1,000 Telstra shares

  • Over the period of a year she gets dividends of A$265

  • To provide them, Telstra made a profit of A$379 on which it paid A$114 tax

  • Jill pays tax on the full $379 but gets a credit of A$114 that can be taken off any other tax she owes that year

  • As with other tax credits, it can be used to cut Jill’s tax bill as far as zero, but not to turn it negative. It can’t be handed to her in cash.

As Keating put it, the tax paid at the company level would be imputed, or allocated to shareholders by means of imputation credits.

But not to all of them. Non-resident (overseas) shareholders couldn’t get them, and nor could shareholders whose dividends hadn’t been franked.

Franking credits

As Keating explained, the tax credit only applied to the extent to which full Australian company tax had been paid; to the extent to which the dividends had been franked (stamped) to indicate that tax had been paid.

Not every company pays the full 30 cents in the dollar in every year. Often it is carrying forward previous losses. Only dividends from profits on which full tax had actually been paid were to be marked “fully franked”. Dividends on which tax had been partly paid were to be marked “partly franked”.

Fully franked dividends became sought after, because they brought with them the biggest franking credits. In a useful side effect, dividend imputation encouraged companies that wanted to look after their shareholders to pay full tax.

Refunds to non taxpayers

Although the particular Australian design arguably was a world first, dividend imputation or something similar is not unusual. Many countries have systems in place that to a greater or lesser degree ensure company profits are taxed only once – among them Canada, New Zealand, Chile, Mexico, Malaysia and Singapore, whose system is called “one-tier” tax.

Many that did adopt it later moved away from it, using the money saved to cut headline tax rates; among them Britain, Ireland Germany and France.

What is unusual is what Australia did next. In 2001 after more than a decade of dividend imputation, the Howard government supercharged it, paying out franking credits in cash to shareholders who didn’t have any or enough tax to offset.

From the point of the view of these non-taxpayers, dividend imputation became a negative income tax: instead of them paying the government money, the government paid them money.

As far as is known, it is an enhancement that has not been copied anywhere.

On one hand, it makes sense because it treats non-taxpayers the same as taxpayers by refunding them the same amount of company tax.

On the other hand, it does not make sense because it means that instead of being taxed once (at either the company or the personal level) as was the original intention, company profits can escape tax altogether.

Untaxed super

From 2007 the change mattered to many more retirees.

The Howard government’s “Simplified Superannuation” package made super benefits paid from a taxed source (that’s most super benefits outside of the public service) tax free when paid to people aged 60 and over.

A quirk in the wording of the Act went further. Not only did super withdrawals become tax free, they also became no longer included in “taxable income” and so didn’t need to be declared on tax forms.

This meant that many retirees on reasonable super incomes were no longer taxed at reasonable rates on their other income, including income from shares which could be untaxed if it fell below the tax free threshold.

And because of the 2001 decision to send dividend imputation cheques to shareholders who were untaxed, these retirees who suddenly found themselves untaxed also got imputation cheques mailed to them from the government.

Self-managed super funds, whose income is tax exempt in the retirement phase, also got imputation cheques.

In July 2017 the Turnbull government wound back tax free super by placing a limiting it to accounts with less than A$1.6 million. The restriction was to hit 1% of super-fund members.

Labor’s proposal

Treasury’s 2015 tax discussion paper prepared for the Abbott government referred to “revenue concerns” about dividend imputation cheques.

They cost the budget just A$550 million in the year the Howard government introduced them, but A$5 billion per year by 2018 and were on track to cost A$8 billion.

Labor’s proposal, announced in mid March 2018, was to return the divided imputation system to where it had been before Howard changed it in 2001, and to where it still is elsewhere. Tax credits could be used to eliminate a tax payment but not to turn it negative.

Labor allowed exceptions for tax exempt bodies such as charities and universities who would continue to receive imputation cheques alongside dividends.

Pensioner guarantee

Two weeks later, in late March, Labor amended its policy by adding a “pensioner guarantee”. Pension and allowance recipients, even part pensioners, would be exempt from the changes and would continue to receive cash payments.

Also exempt would be self-managed super funds with at least one member who was receiving a pension or part-pension at the date of Labor’s announcement, 28 March 2018.

The change cost relatively little (the budget saving over the next four years fell to A$10.7 billion from A$11.4 billion) because most of the imputation cheques go to Australians with too much wealth to get even a part pension.

Self Managed Super Funds

Retail and industry super funds pool their members contributions, and so almost always have tax to reduce, meaning most are would be unaffected by the withdrawal of cash credits.

Self Managed funds usually represent just one person, or a couple; their funds aren’t pooled with anyone else’s. This means that in the retirement phase, where fund earnings are untaxed, most do to have enough tax to reduce. So they get imputation cheques, which they would no longer get when Labor’s policy was implemented.

The Parliamentary Budget Office expects some self-managed funds to change their investment mix and some owners of self-managed funds to transfer their investments to retail or industry funds.

Retirement tax

There is no such thing. The phrase is shorthand for Labor’s proposal to withdraw dividend imputation cheques from dividend recipients who are outside the tax system.

Peter Martin does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors: Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Read more http://theconversation.com/words-that-matter-whats-a-franking-credit-whats-dividend-imputation-and-whats-retiree-tax-111423

How to Spice Up Your Relationship

If you’ve been with your partner for a long time, the flame of your love life may slowly be simmering. Even if you know for sure that you want to spend the rest of your life with your significan...

News Company - avatar News Company

Some good news for a change: Australia's greenhouse gas emissions are set to fall

Renewable energy being installed at a community in the Northern Territory. Researchers have predicted Australia's emissions are set to fall, but warn the renewables deployment rate must continue. Lucy...

Andrew Blakers, Professor of Engineering, Australian National University - avatar Andrew Blakers, Professor of Engineering, Australian National University

Don't blame the teacher: student results are (mostly) out of their hands

We wanted to find out how much classroom factors had to do with why some twins did better than others at school. from shutterstock.comTeachers have very little to do with why some kids are better at s...

Callie Little, Postdoctoral research fellow, University of New England - avatar Callie Little, Postdoctoral research fellow, University of New England

Risky business: how our 'macho' construction culture is killing tradies

The rates of suicide among males working in the construction industry are almost double the rates seen overall among Australian men. From shutterstock.comThe construction and building industries can b...

Donna Bridges, Lecture of sociology, Charles Sturt University - avatar Donna Bridges, Lecture of sociology, Charles Sturt University

Over-the-top policing of bike helmet laws targets vulnerable riders

A cyclist not wearing a helmet can expect to attract the attention of NSW Police – and not always just for that offence. NSW Police/FacebookCycling is often held up as a model of healthy and sus...

Julia Quilter, Associate Professor of Law, University of Wollongong - avatar Julia Quilter, Associate Professor of Law, University of Wollongong

Curious Kids: how does an optical illusion work?

Optical illusions use colour, pictures and shapes that can make our brain and eyes confused. Shutterstock How does an optical illusion work? – Scarlett, age 8, Shellharbour, NSW. Take a loo...

Cedric van den Berg, PhD student, The University of Queensland - avatar Cedric van den Berg, PhD student, The University of Queensland

Bruny review: Heather Rose's new book has a sense of place yet taps into global unease

Scandal strikes a Tasmanian construction project in the novel Bruny. www.shutterstock.comWhen in 2017 Nordstrom began selling US$425 jeans (A$620) covered in fake mud, it seemed the long prophesied &...

Simon Ryan, Associate Professor (Literature), Australian Catholic University - avatar Simon Ryan, Associate Professor (Literature), Australian Catholic University

There's one big problem with Australia's skilled migration program: many employers don't want new migrants

Many skilled migrants in South Australia have found themselves in a classic Catch-22 situation – they can’t get local experience because they don’t have local experience. Shutterstoc...

Andreas Cebulla, Senior Research Fellow, South Australian Centre for Economic Studies , University of Adelaide - avatar Andreas Cebulla, Senior Research Fellow, South Australian Centre for Economic Studies , University of Adelaide

John Setka resigns from ALP, attacks Albanese

Opposition leader Anthony Albanese has finally seen off John Setka from the ALP, with the militant construction union leader capitulating and quitting the party. Setka, who lost a court case he broug...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Why Should You Hire a Landscaping Expert for The House?

If you are like most people, you love spending time outside. When it comes to your home, you want a garden space you can enjoy, no matter the season. Having a green thumb can help you to create a ga...

News Company - avatar News Company

Nationals leader Michael McCormack acknowledges snafu over Hanson dairy deal

Nationals leader Michael McCormack has admitted his party should have better handled agriculture minister Bridget McKenzie’s bring-forward of the planned dairy code. Some Nationals were furious...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Politics with Michelle Grattan: Deputy PM Michael McCormack on the drought and restive Nationals

While the drought continues to hit the Nationals’ constituents hard, the party faces testing terrain on a political level. In this episode of Politics with Michelle Grattan, Deputy Prime Minist...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

What Are the Most Popular Gambling Places in Australia?

Discover the Most Popular Gambling Places in Australia Is it your first time in Australia, and you would like to try your luck in a land-based casino? Perhaps you are a resident who has never vis...

News Company - avatar News Company

If you want to boost the economy, big infrastructure projects won't cut it: new Treasury boss

Treasury secretary Steven Kennedy – in the job for for just weeks after moving across from the department of infrastructure last month – has dismissed talk of spending big on infrastructur...

Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University - avatar Peter Martin, Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

Politicians must mine the divide between coal lobbies and energy companies

BHP has voted to stay in the Minerals Council of Australia. Environmental Change and Security Program/Flickr, CC BY-NC-SAIt’s time we started talking about the principal opponents to action on c...

Christian Downie, Australian Research Council DECRA Fellow, Australian National University - avatar Christian Downie, Australian Research Council DECRA Fellow, Australian National University

'My friends are taking MDMA at raves and music festivals. Is it safe?'

No drug is 100% safe. Wes Mountain My friends are taking ecstasy at raves and music festivals. Is it safe? — Anonymous Key points no drug use, including ecstasy, is 100% safe festivals can p...

Jodie Grigg, Research Associate at the National Drug Research Institute, Curtin University - avatar Jodie Grigg, Research Associate at the National Drug Research Institute, Curtin University

Top Rated Australian Cryptocurrency Exchanges

When looking for the best Australian cryptocurrency exchanges, there are a few main tips and techniques to utilize. Cryptocurrencies are a relatively new concept that focuses on digital assets. Th...

News Company - avatar News Company

Creating and being seen: new projects focus on the rights of artists with disabilities

Artists at work. Studio A.At Studio A, on the fourth floor of the Crows Nest community centre, a group of artists is working quietly. An occasional burst of laughter erupts from a corner of the stud...

Chloe Watfern, Scientia PhD scholar, UNSW - avatar Chloe Watfern, Scientia PhD scholar, UNSW

The robot wears Prada: what happens when AI starts giving out fashion tips?

Can a machine understand style? Facebook's Fashion++ system recommends small changes to an outfit to make it more fashionable. FacebookThe tech giants Amazon, Google and Facebook have all begun to use...

Mark Liu, Chancellors Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Fashion and Textiles Designer, University of Technology Sydney - avatar Mark Liu, Chancellors Postdoctoral Research Fellow, Fashion and Textiles Designer, University of Technology Sydney

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company

LifeStyle

How to Spice Up Your Relationship

If you’ve been with your partner for a long time, the flame of your love life may slowly be si...

4 Perfect Locations for your Destination Wedding in France

France is probably one of the few locations in the world that we synonymise with love so what bett...

Questions to ask yourself before buying your watch

There are more and more watches on the market. And more and more brands are trying to seduce consu...

How to Thoroughly Prepare Children for a Professional Photoshoot at a Studio

Children are only young for a moment, which is why, for a lot of parents, it's essential to take a...