.

  • Written by Kellie Bousfield, Associate Head of School, School of Education, Charles Sturt University
By making funding dependent on school outcomes, the government is intensifying an audit culture that marginalises vulnerable students. from shutterstock.com

This week’s New South Wales budget delivered some good news for education. The government promised 4,600 extra public school teachers, more than 600,000 free TAFE and VET courses, additional funds for building and refurbishing schools, and an allowance for an extra 100 school counsellors or psychologists.

But the government’s commitment came with a caveat. Schools will need to justify these, and future budgetary allocations and spending, through explanations for their need and by delivering quantifiable outcomes.

At first glance, this may appear fair. After all, as NSW Treasurer Dominic Perrottet pointed out:

… parents want to know that every dollar we spend will improve their kids’ education.

However, experience (and research) tell us this simple method of aligning funding with targeted outcomes – essentially providing funding not based on need but on results – can have some unintended consequences. These can be detrimental to the quality of education and particularly affect the most marginalised students.

Funding for outcomes

Outcome budgetingseems to be the buzzword of the NSW 2019-2020 budget. Its intention appears both simple and noble.

In plain terms, it seeks to integrate what it considers previously “unconnected” planning, budgeting and reporting into a coherent framework of performance management – a situation in which government spending can be justified via measurable outcomes.


Outcome budgeting seems to be the buzzword of the latest NSW budget. Budget NSW (screenshot)

According to the NSW government’s budget website, in outcome budgeting:

… it is not just the finances that matter, but how success will be tracked and how citizens will be kept informed throughout delivery. It ensures ongoing focus on value for money, not just during planning but through implementation.

The government has indicated a broad commitment to outcome budgeting across all areas of concern. But the treasurer said education was the first department of concern and will set the stage for the others. As the budget statement notes:

Every cluster in the NSW Government will be following the Department of Education with outcome-focused plans that provide a clear roadmap to delivering results.

Applying outcome budgeting to an area as complex as education is fraught with danger. Arguably, what the NSW government is proposing is a further intensification of the audit culture (think NAPLAN, My School) that has plagued Australian schools for much of the last decade.

Rather than improved academic outcomes, this period in Australian education has been characterised by stagnant and/or declining educational results, both domestically and in international comparisons.

International literature has previously shown an association between an audit culture (a focus on standardised testing) and a decline in educational outcomes. And while specific details of how concrete outcomes will be measured remains scant, the government’s strategic plan suggests it is committed to standardised testing as a basis for measurement.

Focusing on outcomes can hamper teaching

Unsurprisingly, the announced linking of funding to outcomes has generated some criticism in academic and media circles. This is because much research in Australia and overseas has pointed to the profound impact that focusing on accountability and targeted results can have on pedagogy, teachers and students.

Standardised tests such as NAPLAN, when used as a basis for managing performance through the data they provide, can change the role and conduct of teachers. Research shows this can result in:

Teachers engulfed by an audit culture, where results of standardised tests are viewed as the sole indicator of the effectiveness of their teaching, can deem such practices as necessary.

Focusing on standardised testing outcomes has also affected students. This has been evidenced through:

Audit culture can affect vulnerable students the most. Research on NAPLAN, for instance, suggests focusing on standardised test results serves only to lock in outcome inequality for low socio-economic and linguistically diverse students. This is due to teachers having reduced opportunities to enact the pedagogy crucial to such students’ success.

These findings echo similar research in the US and UK demonstrating the disproportionate negative consequences for low socio-economic students and ethnic minorities subject to standardised testing.

There is no question improved educational outcomes are important. As is a plan for how we get there. But how we set about achieving this requires careful consideration and reflection rather than a one-size-fits-all approach across disparate areas of government.

Success in education should not be simplified to concrete outcomes, specifically results in standardised tests, alone.

Kellie Bousfield does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors: Kellie Bousfield, Associate Head of School, School of Education, Charles Sturt University

Read more http://theconversation.com/nsw-budget-giving-schools-extra-money-only-if-they-meet-outcomes-can-hamper-teaching-standards-119087

Morrison says China knows 'where Australia is coming from', after meeting Chinese vice-president

Scott Morrison seized the opportunity of his Jakarta weekend visit for Indonesian President Joko Widodo’s inauguration to obtain a meeting with Chinese Vice President Wang Qishan. Morrison told...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Who's responsible for the slaughtered ex-racehorses, and what can be done?

Animal activists stage a protest during Caulfield Cup day at Caulfield Race Course in Melbourne, following shocking hidden-camera footage revealing the slaughtering of former racehorses. AAP Image/Jam...

Kate Fenner, PhD Candidate (Equine Training and Welfare), University of Sydney - avatar Kate Fenner, PhD Candidate (Equine Training and Welfare), University of Sydney

Science prizes are still a boys' club. Here's how we can change that

At the 2018 Prime Minister's Prizes for Science, only two recipients were women. PM's Prizes for ScienceThis year, five of the seven Prime Minister’s Prizes for Science were awarded to women. Wh...

Justine Shaw, Conservation Biologist, The University of Queensland - avatar Justine Shaw, Conservation Biologist, The University of Queensland

Arrogance destroyed the World Trade Organisation. What replaces it will be even worse

As the public face of globalism, the WTO mobilised protesters. It'll be replaced by the law of the jungle. fuzheado/Flikr, CC BY-SAIn line with his usual practice, Prime Minister Scott Morrison has ba...

John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland - avatar John Quiggin, Professor, School of Economics, The University of Queensland

The Trump presidency should not be shocking. It's a symptom of our cultural malaise

It's a mistake to see Trump as unique or his success as something that could only occur in America. Pete Marovich/Pool/EPADuring the 2016 US presidential campaign, people around the world were regular...

Brendon O'Connor, Associate Professor in American Politics at the United States Studies Centre, University of Sydney - avatar Brendon O'Connor, Associate Professor in American Politics at the United States Studies Centre, University of Sydney

4 ways to talk with vaccine skeptics

If another parent at playgroup says she's not vaccinating her child, what's the best way to respond? from www.shutterstock.comYour neighbour is telling you about his new baby. He feels nervous about v...

Julie Leask, Professor, University of Sydney - avatar Julie Leask, Professor, University of Sydney

Growing numbers of renters are trapped for years in homes they can't afford

Rental stress leaves hundreds of thousands of Australians struggling for years to cover all the other costs of living. Tero Vesalainen/ShutterstockLow-income tenants in Australia are increasingly like...

Hal Pawson, Associate Director - City Futures - Urban Policy and Strategy, City Futures Research Centre, Housing Policy and Practice, UNSW - avatar Hal Pawson, Associate Director - City Futures - Urban Policy and Strategy, City Futures Research Centre, Housing Policy and Practice, UNSW

The voice unmasked: how we hear image, emotion and identity

The Masked singer forces us to rely on our listening skills, while distracting us with crazy costumes. Network 10As the Australian premier season of The Masked Singer draws to a close, fans are liste...

Kristal Spreadborough, Casual Academic, University of New England - avatar Kristal Spreadborough, Casual Academic, University of New England

4 Perfect Locations for your Destination Wedding in France

France is probably one of the few locations in the world that we synonymise with love so what better place for your destination wedding. Spending time in the Parisian countryside can be the most idy...

News Company - avatar News Company

Domestic Disasters - 4 Common Household Problems & How to Avoid Them

Secure, livable housing is one of the necessities to which all humans are entitled. Unfortunately, our homes don't always get the memo. Domestic disasters can strike at any time (even though we all ...

News Company - avatar News Company

How to Write a Catchy Sign to Boost Brand Awareness: Benefits and Tips

In the past century, technological advancements paved the way for the fast-paced world digital business. Since then, most businesses focus their efforts and resources on advertising through the Inte...

Brian Dwyer - avatar Brian Dwyer

Understanding and Looking After Your Digestive System

The human microbiome is made up of trillions of microscopic organisms. The majority of these microbes live in our gut, most of them in the colon and intestines. Playing a vital role in our body, the...

Alex Witt - avatar Alex Witt

VIDEO: Michelle Grattan on the government's drought policy - and the trust divide in politics

Michelle Grattan says the announcement of extra money for drought-stricken farmers "won't be enough" to alleviate pressure on the government on the issue of drought. ShutterstockUniversity of Canberr...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Our ability to manufacture minerals could transform the gem market, medical industries and even help suck carbon from the air

Pictured is a slag pile at Broken Hill in New South Wales. Slag is a man-made waste product created during smelting. Anita Parbhakar-Fox, Author providedLast month, scientists uncovered a mineral cal...

Anita Parbhakar-Fox, Senior Research Fellow in Geometallurgy/Applied Geochemistry, The University of Queensland - avatar Anita Parbhakar-Fox, Senior Research Fellow in Geometallurgy/Applied Geochemistry, The University of Queensland

Lambie stays mute on medevac vote after Senate inquiry splits on party lines

Jacqui Lambie has yet to announce whether she will support the bill to have medevac repealed. AAP/Mick TsikasThe Senate inquiry into repealing medevac has predictably split along party lines, with the...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Sydney's 9,189 'sister politicians' who petitioned Queen Victoria

One spring morning in 1850, over 8,000 Sydneysiders marched through town to protest the resumption of transportation – the act of sending British criminals to Australia. It was the largest pro...

Kiera Lindsey, University of Technology Sydney - avatar Kiera Lindsey, University of Technology Sydney

Penny Whetton: A pioneering climate scientist skilled in the art of life

Penny Whetton, right, addressing a March for Science rally. Her death last month shocked and saddened colleagues. Supplied by familyLast month we lost Dr Penny Whetton - one of the world’s most ...

John M Clarke, Team Leader, Regional Projections, CSIRO - avatar John M Clarke, Team Leader, Regional Projections, CSIRO

​The Coalition government is (again) trying to put the squeeze on the ABC

The Coalition government has reintroduced a bill seeking to mandate the ABC devote more resources to covering regional Australia – a measure that has been defeated before by parliament. Danny Ca...

Fiona R Martin, Senior Lecturer in Convergent and Online Media, University of Sydney - avatar Fiona R Martin, Senior Lecturer in Convergent and Online Media, University of Sydney

Is your horse normal? Now there’s an app for that

Vet: are you happy? Horse: neigh. evilgurl/Flickr, CC BY-NC-SASince ancient times, horse behaviour, and the bond between horses and humans, has been a source of intrigue and fascination. The horse-l...

Paul McGreevy, Professor of Animal Behaviour and Animal Welfare Science, University of Sydney - avatar Paul McGreevy, Professor of Animal Behaviour and Animal Welfare Science, University of Sydney

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company

LifeStyle

4 Perfect Locations for your Destination Wedding in France

France is probably one of the few locations in the world that we synonymise with love so what bett...

Questions to ask yourself before buying your watch

There are more and more watches on the market. And more and more brands are trying to seduce consu...

How to Thoroughly Prepare Children for a Professional Photoshoot at a Studio

Children are only young for a moment, which is why, for a lot of parents, it's essential to take a...

What to Expect at the University of Florida Tour

The University of Florida is a dream college for most aspiring students. Not only because of its p...