.

  • Written by Lin Crase, Professor of Economics and Head of School, University of South Australia

The deal to crank up Adelaide’s desalination plant to make more water available to farmers in the drought-stricken Murray-Darling Basin makes no sense.

It involves the federal government paying the South Australian government up to A$100 million to produce more water for Adelaide using the little-used desalination plant.

The plant was commissioned in 2007 at the height of the millennium drought. It can produce up to 100 gigalitres of water a year – enough to fill 40,000 olympic sized swimming pools. But has been used sparingly, operating at its minimum mode of 8 gigalitres a year, because of the expense of turning seawater into freshwater.

The Adelaide Desalination Plant. Vmenkov/Wikimedia, CC BY-SA

Adelaide has continued to mostly draw water from local reservoirs and the River Murray, which on average has supplied about half the city’s water (sometimes much more).

But with federal funding, the desal plant will be turned on full bore. This will free up 100 gigalitres of water from the Murray River allocated to Adelaide for use by farmers upstream in the Murray Darling’s southern basin.

The southern Murray–Darling Basin. ABARES, CC BY-NC

The federal government expects the water to be used to grow an extra 120,000 tonnes of fodder for livestock. The water will be sold to farmers at a discount rate of A$100 a megalitre. That’s 10 cents per 1,000 litres.

By comparison, the residential price for that water in Adelaide would be A$2.39 to A$3.70 per 1,000 litres.

The production cost of desalinated water is about 95 cents per 1,000 litres when there’s rainwater already stored, according to a cost-benefit study published by the SA Department of Environment and Water in 2016. That means the total cost for the 100 gigalitres will be about A$95 million.

So the federal government is effectively paying A$95 million to sell water for A$10 million: a loss to taxpayers of A$85 million.

The Conversation, CC BY-ND

What do we get for the money?

The discounted water provided to individual farmers will be capped at no more than 25 megalitres. The farmers must agree to not sell the water to others and to use it to grow fodder for livestock.

There are many different forms of fodder but livestock producers most favour lucerne hay because it is highly nutritious. But it is also more expensive than cereal, pasture or straw hay.

The amount of hay that can be grown with a megalitre of irrigation water depends on many things, but 120,000 tonnes with 100 gigalitres is possible in the right conditions.

In the Murray-Darling southern basin lucerne hay currently sells for A$450 to A$600 a tonne. That would make the market value of 120,000 tonnes of lucerne A$54 million to A$72 million.

It means, on a best-case scenario, the federal government will be spending A$85 million to subsidise the production of hay worth A$72 million to its producers.


Read more: Australia's drought relief package hits the political spot but misses the bigger point


The reality of farming

In practice farms and farmers are incredible diverse, so not all irrigators will necessarily grow lucerne. Alternative fodders such as pasture or cereal hay generally have much lower market values. Which meaning the value of the fodder produced may be much less than the best-case scenario.

It’s worrying that this policy shows such little regard for farming realities. It appears to have been crafted on the premise that every farmer has the same land, the same equipment and the same needs.

Dictating the water must be used for a single purpose runs counter to the needs of the agriculture sector. If farmers could put it to a more effective use, why not allow it?

In addition, it’s not clear how all the monitoring will be done to maintain compliance over such a restrictive regime.

What measures will prevent farmers buying the discounted water and then simply selling an equivalent amount of any carry-over allocation at the going rate of up to $1,000 a megalitre?


Read more: Drought and climate change are driving high water prices in the Murray-Darling Basin


How will the government distinguish between the fodder grown with the 25 megalitres provided at low cost and any other fodder harvested on the same farm? How much will it cost to monitor and enforce such arrangements?

The difficulty of answering these types of questions is precisely the reason why countries in the former eastern bloc failed to adequately provide for their populations. Telling people what crop to grow, when to grow, how to water the crop and how it should be consumed has not worked in the past. Farm businesses that respond to prices and use inputs, including water, in a way that suits their long- term commercial needs are generally better off.

It seems a long way from the type of national drought policy Australia needs. It’s hard to see how a policy of this kind does anything other than waste a large amount of public money and disrupt important market mechanisms in agriculture in the process.

Lin Crase receives funding from the Australian Research Council and the Australian Centre for International Agricultural Research.

Authors: Lin Crase, Professor of Economics and Head of School, University of South Australia

Read more http://theconversation.com/up-the-creek-the-85-million-plan-to-desalinate-water-for-drought-relief-126681

5 Things to Keep in Mind When Renting Skip Bins

Renting a skip bin is an easy way to ensure that all your rubbish is collected and sorted properly, especially in situations where you might not be able to rely on local rubbish collection services ...

News Company - avatar News Company

Job losses expected as NZ's broadcasting sector faces biggest overhaul in a decade

New Zealand's commercial broadcasters are in trouble and the government is considering a complete restructure of public broadcasting. from www.shutterstock.com, CC BY-NDNew Zealand’s broadcastin...

Merja Myllylahti, Co-Director JMAD research center, Auckland University of Technology - avatar Merja Myllylahti, Co-Director JMAD research center, Auckland University of Technology

Can Indigenous Australians be deported as 'aliens'? A High Court decision will show us the strength of modern colonial power

Federal Immigration Minister David Coleman has cancelled the visas of two overseas born Indigenous men with a criminal past. They are, Coleman says, aliens with no automatic right to live in Australia...

Dominic O'Sullivan, Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences, Auckland University of Technology and Associate Professor of Political Science, Charles Sturt University - avatar Dominic O'Sullivan, Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Health and Environmental Sciences, Auckland University of Technology and Associate Professor of Political Science, Charles Sturt University

'One of the most poignant opera scenes I have ever experienced': Pinchgut’s Farnace

This new production of Farnace overwhelms with delight. Brett Boardman/Pinchgut OperaReview: Farnace, composed by Vivaldi, Pinchgut Opera When a performance of Farnace was cancelled at the theatre o...

Daniela Kaleva, Associate Head Research and Scholarship, Australian Institute of Music - avatar Daniela Kaleva, Associate Head Research and Scholarship, Australian Institute of Music

Politics with Michelle Grattan: Andrew Hastie on foreign influence, security and veteran mental health

Chinese government influence and interference has been a contentious issue in Australia politics in the past year. Weighing up concerns about foreign money in state and federal campaigns, candidates...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Litigation is the real reason financial reports are becoming harder to read

Westpac can expect a bumper turnout of shareholders at its annual general meeting in Sydney on Thursday, many of them angry at its alleged role in facilitating child exploitation in the Philippines, i...

Mark Humphery-Jenner, Associate Professor of Finance, UNSW - avatar Mark Humphery-Jenner, Associate Professor of Finance, UNSW

'How do I clean my penis?'

Wes Mountain/The Conversation, CC BY-ND Growing up, no one ever gave me the rundown on how or what I should do to keep my penis clean […] I’ve never read any reliable answer beyond washi...

David King, Senior Lecturer, The University of Queensland - avatar David King, Senior Lecturer, The University of Queensland

Voters send sharp message to politicians about trust: ANU Australian Election Study

Following the 2019 federal election, only 59% of voters said they were satisfied with the way democracy was working. AAP/Mick TsikasThe Australian National University’s election study has unders...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Finally, your electricity bill looks set to fall. Here's how much you could save

The renewables revolution is starting to pay off: our electricity bills are set to fall. AAP/Julian SmithHousehold electricity bills in Australia have increased sharply in the past decade. But new off...

Tim Nelson, Associate Professor of Economics, Griffith University - avatar Tim Nelson, Associate Professor of Economics, Griffith University

Estonia didn't deliver its PISA results on the cheap, and neither will Australia

Estonia spends less per student than Australia, but its average wages are lower too. Ruslan Valeev/UnsplashEducation news in Australia last week was dominated by Australia’s worst ever showing i...

Peter Goss, School Education Program Director, Grattan Institute - avatar Peter Goss, School Education Program Director, Grattan Institute

What is sodium lauryl sulfate and is it safe to use?

SLS is a known irritant to human skin. But if it's only in contact with your skin for a short time, it's probably OK. from www.shutterstock.comIf you’ve ever Googled the causes of a skin compla...

Yousuf Mohammed, Dermatology researcher, The University of Queensland - avatar Yousuf Mohammed, Dermatology researcher, The University of Queensland

Science needs true diversity to succeed -- and Australian astronomy shows how we can get it

Australian astronomy punches well above its weight, in terms of the research it leads and the facilities it houses. We have made remarkable discoveries in the past year alone. Our scientists have re...

Lisa Kewley, Director, ARC Centre for Excellence in All-Sky Astrophysics in 3D, Australian National University - avatar Lisa Kewley, Director, ARC Centre for Excellence in All-Sky Astrophysics in 3D, Australian National University

50 years on from the Melbourne Transportation Plan, what can we learn from its legacy?

The Melbourne Transportation Plan included every freeway and major arterial road built in the city since 1969. Shuang Li/ShutterstockThis is the first article in a series to mark the 50th anniversary ...

Liam Davies, PhD Candidate, Centre for Urban Research, RMIT University - avatar Liam Davies, PhD Candidate, Centre for Urban Research, RMIT University

State Library Victoria proves libraries aren't just about books: they're about community

Not the hushed or book-filled library experience you might expect. Patrick Rodriguez/SLVPublic libraries embody the values of democracy by offering free access to knowledge. But the role of contempora...

Sarah Backhouse, Research Fellow, Learning Environments Applied Research Network (LEaRN), University of Melbourne - avatar Sarah Backhouse, Research Fellow, Learning Environments Applied Research Network (LEaRN), University of Melbourne

Evangelical churches believe men should control women. That's why they breed domestic violence

Evangelical church teachings create fertile ground for domestic violence, its justification and its concealment. ShutterstockThis article is the first in a series exploring gender and Christianity. J...

Vicki Lowik, PhD candidate, CQUniversity Australia - avatar Vicki Lowik, PhD candidate, CQUniversity Australia

Why Vieques Puerto Rico Should Be on Your Bucket List

When visiting remote islands, most people would say that you only need to stay a couple of days there. But when you decide to visit Vieques, Puerto Rico, you can strike that idea out of your mind...

News Company - avatar News Company

Albanese accuses Facebook of shrugging off fakery

Anthony Albanese has also criticised the government for attacking freedom of the press and the right to protest. AAP/Mick TsikasOpposition leader Anthony Albanese is sharply critical of Facebook for f...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Latest Wednesday Lotto Results

Wednesday Lotto draw 3917 Lucky numbers for this draw were 43 followed by 25. The rest of the winning numbers are 44, 33, 7 and lastly 15. So, one even and five odd numbers are in the lucky num...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Chinese students top the PISA rankings, but some Shanghai parents are turning away from the school system

China is fast becoming a middle-class nation. Ewan Yap/UnsplashAustralian 15 year olds were around three and a half years behind their counterparts in China in maths, according to the OECD’s lat...

Hannah Soong, Senior Lecturer in Teacher Education Practice, School of Education, University of South Australia - avatar Hannah Soong, Senior Lecturer in Teacher Education Practice, School of Education, University of South Australia

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company

LifeStyle

Latest Wednesday Lotto Results

Wednesday Lotto draw 3917 Lucky numbers for this draw were 43 followed by 25. The rest of the...

Ways Love and Relationships Benefit Body and Mind

Being in a happy relationship is great. You always have someone to greet you when you come home ...

The Importance of Smiling: How You Can Smile More

Happiness is something we all strive for and is often just out of reach. Of course, it’s impos...

5 Things to Do On Your Wedding Morning

After months of meticulous planning, wedding mornings usually find the bride excited but stressed ...