Viw Magazine

Men's Weekly

.

  • Written by Andrew Robinson, Communications Scientist and Scholar, Australian National University
imageIn the Global Biodiversity Information Facility there are 682,447 records of human encounters with dandelions. from www.shutterstock.com

The idea seems wonderful - a phone app that allows you to take a photo of a plant or animal and receive immediate species identification and other information about it. A “Shazam for nature” so to speak.

We are building huge repositories of data related to our natural environments, making this idea a reality.

But there are ethical concerns that should be addressed: about how data is collected and shared, who has the right to share it and how we use public data for machine learning.

And there’s a bigger concern – whether such apps change what it means to be human.


Read moreCan machines really tell us if we’re sick?


Encounters with dandelions

Oliver Sacks, the brilliant neurologist and author, once arranged to take a group of his patients on a field trip to the New York Botanic Garden. One of his patients, a severely autistic young man named Steve, hadn’t stepped outside the facility for years. He never spoke; indeed, the doctors believed him incapable of speech.

In the gardens with Sacks, however, the invigorated Steve plucked a flower, and to the surprise of everyone, uttered the word “dandelion.”

Over the last decade, this affinity so many of us feel for nature – what the famed biologist Edward Wilson termed “biophilia” – has resulted in an explosion of big data. In the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF, an online database run out of Copenhagen) there are 682,447 records of human encounters with dandelions. Overall, the database holds more than 850 million observations of over a million different species of flora and fauna.

imageThe whale shark is the world’s largest fish species.from www.shutterstock.com

It’s an impressive achievement, a gestating, global catalogue of life. It allows us to see the world in new ways. For example just this year, thanks to the more than 42,000 recorded sightings from more than 5,000 participants using WhaleShark.org, we’ve gained unprecedented insight into the behaviour of the world’s largest fish species. Or on an bigger scale, the millions of bird observations generated through an app called eBird have allowed us to visualise the precise migratory routes of over a hundred different bird species.

At the same time, in an outcome largely unforeseen by its early collectors, info-engineers are using the data to train artificial intelligence (AI), particularly computer vision apps to help us interpret the plants and animals we see around us. And these tools are raising some interesting, sometimes troubling questions.

Joseph Banks in your pocket

In one sense, of course, such tools are magical. The fictional tricorder of Star Trek is a magnificent device, scanning alien life forms, making them familiar. If we had a version on Earth, it’d be the equivalent of a pocket-sized Joseph Banks, a trusty sidekick of discovery, filling us with a sense of confidence and control.

In China the latest version of the Baidu browser (a so-called Chinese Google) comes with a plant recognition feature built into it. Point your camera at a dandelion and you’ll see the Chinese name for it - 蒲公英. Such apps are triggering a new wave of botanical interest among the general population in China.

But there are also questions about these AI tools interfering with our ability - perhaps a human need - to easily transfer our unique nature expertise to, or gain expertise from, other people. Is the amount of resources going into developing AI matched by what we invest in developing ecological literacy within the billions of supercomputers in peoples’ skulls?


Read more:How do you know that what you know is true? That’s epistemology


There are questions about data bias. A disproportionate number of data collectors - often called “citizen scientists” - are first world hobbyists, birdwatchers, camera geeks. Typically then, the data comes from a relatively non-diverse sector of society.

There are questions about ownership, data appropriation, human agency. Who’s going to own and control the AI? Will the people whose expertise has trained the AI be fairly acknowledged, respected, rewarded?

imageWhat plant is that?from www.shutterstock.com

Or is all that data, as the US economist Philip Mirowski recently argued, nothing more than “the donation of unpaid work to privately owned entities” - entities who will digest and then regurgitate the information into yet another online product we can’t live without? If you search the terms of popular citizen science apps, you’re unlikely to find any mention of how your data might be used to train AI systems.

Empire building

There’s a sense of déjà vu here. The botanical classification conducted by such scientific luminaries as Carl Linnaeus and Joseph Banks – the book Systema Naturae was a sort of GBIF of its day – is often associated with the big data activity of empire building. As explained by the essayist Anne Fadiman in Collecting Nature, botanists would travel to remote parts of the world, find a species which had been known by a local name for centuries:

[…] rechristen it with a Latin binomial, and presto! It became a tiny British colony.

Subsequent generations, meanwhile, would grow up in a world where the only meaningful descriptions of nature existed in empire-approved systems of classified truth: museums, libraries, the biology labs of universities.


Read more:From Joseph Banks to big data, herbaria bring centuries-old science into the digital age


“The real danger [of AI],” writes the philosopher Daniel C. Dennett, “is that we will overestimate the comprehension of our latest thinking tools, prematurely ceding authority to them far beyond their competence”.

Perhaps we’ll cede control; perhaps we’ll have it wrested away. For the developer of nature identification apps, what incentive exists to disabuse us of the Star Trek Tricorder illusion?

The Colorado-based PlantSnap, for example, claims to be training its AI on “50,000 new species per month, and will have every species on Earth covered by the end of 2017”. You could argue this is not just misleading, it’s impossible. A significant portion of plants are yet to be discovered, and far more have yet to be photographed in the wild.

What is human perception?

According to a developer of the Merlin BirdID app, a computer vision tool trained on eBird’s collection of more than 70 million bird photos,

the state-of-the-art in computer vision is rapidly approaching that of human perception.

But what is human perception? It’s easy to forget that each record in all that training data represents - like Sack’s autistic patient in New York - a special act of observation, a sudden spark of curiosity, a unique moment of seeing that belongs to the individual.


Read more:Three visual illusions that reveal the hidden workings of the brain


One thing’s for sure: when it comes to developing AI, there’s an urgent need for more thinking, more consideration, a broader diversity of viewpoints. In developing AI tools, can we program them to value the creative act of human perception - the authentic, the spontaneous, the unpredictable?

Or maybe as Amy Webb, a tech futurist at New York University, has recently proposed, we should establish data sanctuaries. Here, like in nature reserves, our data could roam wild and free, forever untouched by AI, governments, corporate interests. Perhaps a similar space - or a duration of time between data input and response - is needed to protect our unique relationship with the natural world.

imageThe scent of violet ‘makes you want everything’ but ‘makes you sick of things a minute later.’from www.shutterstock.com

In Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, the lovelorn bachelor Orsino, makes an interesting observation of violets. Their scent, he declares, is like romantic love, it

makes you want everything, but it makes you sick of things a minute later, no matter how good they are.

It’s an astonishing insight, and four centuries later, this insight was scientifically confirmed: the beta-ionone in violets, researchers discovered, produces an anosmic affect in the human olfactory system, allowing you to perceive the scent one moment, only for it to vanish (like romantic love) the next.

This exploration of the natural world - this observing, comparing, playing, discovering, loving - is an impulse that’s core to our humanity, and one, I’d suggest, we should be careful not to lose.

Andrew Robinson is co-founder and CEO of the QuestaGame app.

Authors: Andrew Robinson, Communications Scientist and Scholar, Australian National University

Read more http://theconversation.com/ai-is-learning-from-our-encounters-with-nature-and-thats-a-concern-88484

Why the Humble Pizza Box Is a Cornerstone of Food Packaging

Few items in the world of food packaging are as iconic and universally recognized as the pizza box. More than just a container, it is a vi...

Automatic Sliding Screen Door: A Blend of Convenience and Modern Design

Modern homes and businesses are constantly evolving to embrace innovations that combine convenience, security, and style. Among these inno...

Your Go-To Electrical Wholesaler in Sydney for Quality Sparkie Supplies

Let's be fair dinkum, when you're a electrical technision in Sydney, the last thing you want is to be running around like a headless chook l...

Why Doctors Recommend Earplugs for Flying with Sinus Issues

Air travel is convenient, but for people with sinus issues, it can be anything but comfortable. The pressure changes that occur during takeo...

Tradies Make Great Money - So Why Aren't Kids Becoming Apprentices?

Jack loved building, fixing, and improving, and always assumed he would become a tradie like his dad. However, his dreams hit the skids when...

Breastfeeding for Working Mothers: How to Make It Work at Work

Being a breastfeeding working mothers can at times be quite a challenge. Mothers oftentimes wonder if they are capable of expressing milk, s...

Quietly Productive: How Smart Design and Flexible Furniture are Transforming Australian Offices in 2026

For decades, Australian workplaces have been shaped by the open-plan office. Once celebrated as the ultimate collaboration hub, it is now ...

Can’t Afford a First Home in Brisbane? Buy an Investment Property in Regional Queensland

You’re not the only one that is struggling to afford a home. First homes in Brisbane cost an arm and a leg and possibly a few organs too! ...

Understanding Airflow Requirements for Efficient Evaporative Cooling

Evaporative cooling works on a simple principle: drawing warm air through water-saturated pads and circulating the cooled air throughout a...

Garage Door Torsion Springs: What They Are and Why They Matter

Garage doors might seem simple, but they rely on a system of components that work together to provide smooth and balanced movement. One of...

Why a Retractable Hose Reel Is a Must-Have for Every Australian Property

When managing outdoor spaces, whether residential, commercial, or industrial, water management tools are essential. Among the most practic...

7 Signs Your Lorry Needs a Diesel Mechanic, Stat!

Your lorry is the backbone of your business. When it's running smoothly, everything else tends to fall into place. But what happens when t...

Mean Mother Air Compressor and Autostrada Cruise Control: Enhancing the Journey

Modern 4WD accessories like the Mean Mother air compressor and Autostrada cruise control systems transform both capability and comfort for...

Why Real Estate Is a Smart Long-Term Investment

When it comes to building wealth and securing financial stability, few opportunities stand as tall as real estate. Unlike short-term venture...

The Ultimate Guide to Building a Home Gym on a Budget

For many people, the idea of building a home gym feels expensive and overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. The truth is, you don’t ne...

Red Flags to Look Out for When Buying an Investment Property

When you're looking to buy a property to rent out, it is a great way to build wealth. But not every property is a good deal. To make a smart...

The Complete Guide to Navigating the Home Buying Process

Buying a home in Australia is a wild ride. There’s the pressure, the excitement, and the endless scrolling of properties on apps like youâ...

The Ultimate Guide to Building a Capsule Wardrobe

There is nothing more infuriating than seeing getting dressed in the morning as a frustrating chore. If you spend mornings standing in front...

Simple Daily Habits That Improve Balance and Flexibility

Have you ever noticed how easily children can twist, stretch, and balance without a second thought? As adults, we often lose that natural ag...

Modern Luxury on a Budget: Interior Design Hacks That Work

Luxury doesn’t always mean expensive, although that’s what we go for when we try to add it to our home. In design, luxury can be a lot o...