.

  • Written by Anthony Forsyth, Professor of Workplace Law, RMIT University
Israel Folau is claiming that Rugby Australia unlawfully sacked him because of his religion. The organisation, however, contends the rugby star violated the terms of its code of conduct by discriminating against LGBTQ people. Lukas Coch/AAP

Former Wallabies rugby star Israel Folau is the latest in a series of Australian employees to lose their jobs because of social media posts in recent years.

Through a combination of common law rules and broadly expressed codes of conduct, employers have increasingly been able to control their workers’ private activities, including on social media.

But what makes Folau’s case different is that it sets up a clash between employment contract law and legal protections against discrimination on the basis of religion.

This could set an important employment law precedent for future cases like this, which is especially contentious at a time when religious freedom is being so fiercely debated in Australia.

What claim has Folau brought?

Rugby Australia terminated Folau’s employment contract last month after a tribunal determined his actions had breached the organisation’s code of conduct. The offending behaviour was an Instagram post by Folau in April, warning homosexuals (among others): “Hell Awaits You. Repent! Only Jesus Saves.”


Read more: Egging the question: can your employer sack you for what you say or do in your own time?


Folau has now brought a claim under Section 772 of the Fair Work Act alleging the termination was because of his religion and, therefore, unlawful.

The application argues that as a manifestation of his Christian religion, including regular church attendance and preaching, Folau is:

…compelled to communicate the word of God and the message contained within the Bible.

According to media outlets, he is claiming around A$5 million in lost salary and an additional A$5 million in compensation for other missed opportunities, including sponsorships.

What the Fair Work Act says in cases like this

Rugby Australia maintains that Folau was dismissed not because of his religious beliefs, but because he breached the player code of conduct.

The code is typical of that of many businesses. It requires players to treat everyone equally and with dignity, regardless of their sexual orientation; not to use social media to breach expected standards of behaviour; and not to make public comments or otherwise act contrary to the best interests of the game.

What makes Folau’s claim unique is that it depends on the court’s view of whether he was dismissed for reasons that included his religion, as specified under Section 772 of the Fair Work Act.


Read more: The 'gay wedding cake' dilemma: when religious freedom and LGBTI rights intersect


This claim could be easier for Folau to prove than another part of the Fair Work Act commonly relied upon in discrimination cases, Section 351.

Case law tells us that Section 351 requires the employee to prove an employer was motivated to discriminate against him or her because of religion. So, if an employer can point to an employee’s breach of their employment obligations as the reason for dismissal – instead of a discriminatory motive – then the employee’s claim fails.

In contrast, under Section 772, Folau only has to show that his religion was merely among the reasons for the dismissal.

However, in order to make his case, he will also need to demonstrate that his Instagram post constituted an exercise of his religion.

There are some big questions to be resolved here: how far does a person’s right of religious expression extend? Does being a Christian necessarily mean you can express the views of your faith in any public forum?

And does it allow Folau to express his views in the way that he did (noting that he says he was simply quoting from the Bible)?

Rugby Australia chief Raelene Castle says Folau repeatedly ignored warnings about his behaviour on social media. David Gray/AAP

Are there any precedents in case law?

Discrimination law doesn’t help us out much here.

Various state and territory laws protect a person from being discriminated against due to religious “belief”, “conviction” or “activity.” However, the case law shows that only certain characteristics of those who observe a particular religion fall within these protections, for example, a Hindu who practices fasting, or a Sikh wearing a turban. Previous cases haven’t dealt with the question of speech associated with a person’s religion.

For further guidance, we can turn to cases involving an employee’s right to express political opinions. But here, too, we find a bit of a mixed bag.

Academics seemingly have more latitude to express political opinions because their free speech rights are backed up by “intellectual freedom” clauses found in most university enterprise agreements.


Read more: Explainer: does Rugby Australia have legal grounds to sack Israel Folau for anti-gay social media posts?


This enabled former James Cook University physics professor Peter Ridd to successfully contest his dismissal for public comments critical of climate science. Academic freedom was also behind the claim mooted by La Trobe University’s Roz Ward, who was suspended in 2016 for social media comments criticising the “racist Australian flag,” before the university eventually backed down.

By comparison, federal public servants are subject to very restrictive policies curtailing their free speech rights.

However, the case of former Department of Immigration official Michaela Banerji shows that public service employees may be able to rely on the implied constitutional freedom of political communication. She won a workers’ compensation case on the basis that her dismissal for anonymous tweets criticising government policies breached her constitutional rights. The federal government is now contesting that ruling in the High Court.

New territory for employment law

Outside the academic and public sector contexts, we don’t yet have a definitive ruling on the apparent conflict between an employer’s right to control employees’ social media comments and the protections of religious or political freedom found in discrimination law.

Many of these cases settle out of court, such as Angela Williamson’s claim against Cricket Australia for unfair termination following tweets she sent that were critical of Tasmanian government policy on access to abortion.

It’s highly likely that a settlement will be reached in the Folau case, as well. But if it does go to trial, I think the employer’s contractual right to impose standards of behaviour will trump the rugby star’s right to express his religious views.

Court rulings have tended to favour employers seeking to enforce their behavioural policies and codes, including the regulation of employees’ private activities. The Folau case is an important opportunity to see whether the right to express religious views can halt the steady march of employer control in the era of social media.

Anthony Forsyth has received research funding from organisations including the Business Council of Australia, the Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union, the Fair Work Commission and Victorian Government. The views expressed in this article are his own. Anthony blogs on workplace issues at: https://labourlawdownunder.com.au/

Authors: Anthony Forsyth, Professor of Workplace Law, RMIT University

Read more http://theconversation.com/why-the-israel-folau-case-could-set-an-important-precedent-for-employment-law-and-religious-freedom-118455

VIDEO: Michelle Grattan on the family law inquiry - and the UN climate change summit

University of Canberra Deputy Vice-Chancellor Leigh Sullivan discusses Scott Morrison’s new family law inquiry with Michelle Grattan. They also speak of the developments in the Tamil family from...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Climate explained: why don't we have electric aircraft?

CC BY-ND Climate Explained is a collaboration between The Conversation, Stuff and the New Zealand Science Media Centre to answer your questions about climate change. If yo...

Dries Verstraete, Senior Lecturer in Aerospace Design and Propulsion, University of Sydney - avatar Dries Verstraete, Senior Lecturer in Aerospace Design and Propulsion, University of Sydney

Be excellent: how ancient virtues can guide our responses to the climate crisis

What would Socrates say about coal mining? Or recycling? www.shutterstock.comAs world chiefs and youth leaders gather in New York at the United Nations Climate Action Summit, many of us as individua...

Roger Crisp, Professorial Fellow, Dianoia Institute of Philosophy, Australian Catholic University - avatar Roger Crisp, Professorial Fellow, Dianoia Institute of Philosophy, Australian Catholic University

A shot of hope in the face of climate despair

We have a path forward through climate change. Ellie Barr/Unsplash, CC BY-SAHope, like a slinky, springs eternal. While rage, fear and disgust are all appropriate responses to the realities of climate...

Madeleine De Gabriele, Deputy Editor: Energy + Environment - avatar Madeleine De Gabriele, Deputy Editor: Energy + Environment

It's safest to avoid e-cigarettes altogether – unless vaping is helping you quit smoking

The recent vaping-related deaths in the US have brought the issue into the spotlight around the world. From shutterstock.comHealth authorities in the United States are investigating 530 cases of lung ...

Coral Gartner, Associate Professor, School of Public Health, The University of Queensland - avatar Coral Gartner, Associate Professor, School of Public Health, The University of Queensland

What is the charge of concealment of birth and why is it still happening in Australia?

There has been a long history of women being charged with, and prosecuted for, concealment of birth both within WA and the rest of Australia. ShutterstockIn August, a 24-year-old woman appeared before...

Amanda Gardiner, Lecturer, Edith Cowan University - avatar Amanda Gardiner, Lecturer, Edith Cowan University

We want to learn about climate change from weather presenters, not politicians

Melbourne's ABC weather presenter Paul Higgins discussing a trend towards warmer April days. ABC/MCCCRHOne of the great paradoxes of climate change communication in Australia is that politicians comma...

David Holmes, Director, Climate Change Communication Research Hub, Monash University - avatar David Holmes, Director, Climate Change Communication Research Hub, Monash University

Another stolen generation looms unless Indigenous women fleeing violence can find safe housing

In Western Australia more than half the children placed in state care are Aboriginal. The state government committed this month to reducing this over-representation, in a move that parallels the Closi...

Kyllie Cripps, Scientia Felllow and Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law UNSW Sydney, UNSW - avatar Kyllie Cripps, Scientia Felllow and Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law UNSW Sydney, UNSW

Ignoring young people's climate change fears is a recipe for anxiety

This story is part of Covering Climate Now, a global collaboration of more than 250 news outlets to strengthen coverage of the climate story. Thousands of school students across Australia are expecte...

Rachael Sharman, Senior Lecturer in Psychology, University of the Sunshine Coast - avatar Rachael Sharman, Senior Lecturer in Psychology, University of the Sunshine Coast

Friday essay: on the ending of a friendship

Shutterstock Friendship is an incomparable, immeasurable boon to me, and a source of life — not metaphorically but literally. -Simone Weil About eight years ago, I went to dinner with a de...

Kevin John Brophy, Emeritus Professor of Creative writing, University of Melbourne - avatar Kevin John Brophy, Emeritus Professor of Creative writing, University of Melbourne

We don't need another inquiry into family law – we need action

Over the next 12 months, a joint parliamentary committee will examine Australia’s family law system. It will be led by conservative Liberal MP Kevin Andrews and One Nation leader Pauline Hanson...

Miranda Kaye, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, University of Technology Sydney - avatar Miranda Kaye, Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Law, University of Technology Sydney

Procurement’s role in climate change: putting government money where policy needs to go

Governments can choose to spend money in ways that support climate change policy, including a shift to electric vehicle fleets. from www.shutterstock.com, CC BY-NDThis story is part of Covering Climat...

Barbara Allen, Senior Lecturer in Public Management, Victoria University of Wellington - avatar Barbara Allen, Senior Lecturer in Public Management, Victoria University of Wellington

Why do men have nipples?

Men have nipples because of a quirk in how embryos develop. But that's only part of the story of this seemingly redundant body part. from www.shutterstock.comWomen’s nipples have long been a sou...

Michelle Moscova, Senior Lecturer in Anatomy, UNSW - avatar Michelle Moscova, Senior Lecturer in Anatomy, UNSW

Your brain has 'landmarks' that drive neural traffic and help you make hard decisions

The human brain has an estimated 100 billion neurons and 100 trillion neural connections. shutterstockBrain regions exchange information by sending and receiving signals through a network of nerve co...

Caio Seguin, PhD candidate, University of Melbourne - avatar Caio Seguin, PhD candidate, University of Melbourne

It's Newstart pay rise day. You're in line for 24 cents, which is peanuts

The extra 24 cents per day can buy an extra 36 peanuts per day, more if you buy in bulk. ShutterstockNewstart recipients and other Australians on benefits get their half-yearly pay rise today (and als...

Peter Martin., Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University - avatar Peter Martin., Visiting Fellow, Crawford School of Public Policy, Australian National University

The big budget question is why the surplus wasn't big

Treasurer Josh Frydenberg and Finance Minister Mathias Cormann unveil a budget outcome as good as balanced on Thursday. Lukas Coch/AAPThe budget was for practical purposes in neither deficit nor in su...

Warren Hogan, Industry Professor, University of Technology Sydney - avatar Warren Hogan, Industry Professor, University of Technology Sydney

Vital Signs: NBN's new price plans are too little, too late

Lack of speed kills: finally NBN Co is thinking about a genuinely 21st century offering for customers. www.shutterstock.comThis week NBN Co announced pricing changes for the National Broadband Network...

Richard Holden, Professor of Economics, UNSW - avatar Richard Holden, Professor of Economics, UNSW

Grattan on Friday: Morrison government solid on industrial relations reform but bootlicks One Nation on family law

John Howard is remembered by his Liberal tribe as a reformer, but his legacy is mixed. The GST has endured but he essentially doomed his government when he let his ideological obsession with industria...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

How rising temperatures affect our health

The first half of 2019 is the equal hottest on record and summer is set to be a scorcher. Chayathorn Lertpanyaroj/ShutterstockThis story is part of Covering Climate Now, a global collaboration of more...

Liz Hanna, Honorary Senior Fellow, Australian National University - avatar Liz Hanna, Honorary Senior Fellow, Australian National University

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company

LifeStyle

Yvonne Allen: Eight ways to super impress someone on a first date

According to Yvonne Allen well known relationship mentor, psychologist and matchmaker, a first dat...

Picking The Right Crystal Yoni Egg: Tips And Instructions

When you are ready to pick your own crystal yoni egg, you need to decide what you will use it for...

Top 5 Tips for Paddleboarding In Whitewater

Paddleboarding can be relaxing as well as intense. If you occasionally want to do something differen...

3 Most Promising Career Occupations for Graduates in 2019

Studying in college is a great adventure which opens up lots of career opportunities. Yet, at times...