.

  • Written by Mark Pearson, Professor of Journalism and Social Media, Griffith Centre for Social and Cultural Research, Griffith University, Griffith University
Interviews from a range of sensitive research topics may be at risk. These include immigration, crime and corruption. Shutterstock

Each year, academics and students make countless applications for research ethics approval, based on the promise of confidentiality to their interview subjects. Interviewees sometimes offer academic researchers information that might be self-incriminating or might jeopardise the rights and liberties of others they’re discussing.

But Australia’s metadata retention laws can lead to the identification and even incrimination of the very people whose identities academic researchers have promised to keep secret for their work.


Read more: Think your metadata is only visible to national security agencies? Think again


Imagine, for instance, a criminologist conducting a project examining white collar crime in banking and financial services. The academic’s confidential interviews with former company directors and executives might elicit specific and revealing answers. It could lead to potential redundancy or even jail time, depending on their vulnerability and culpability.

Under the metadata laws, government agencies make hundreds of thousands of requests to Australian telcos each year for their customers’ phone and internet communications metadata.

For the criminologist, this means relevant agencies can ask telcos to access his or her metadata in the form of call records and computer IP addresses. This means they can identify whether a person of interest has been in communication with the researcher and is the possible source of incriminating material. Other investigations and legal steps might then follow.

Interviews about a range of sensitive research topics may be at risk. These include immigration, crime and corruption, national security, policing, politics, international relations and policy.

The impact of metadata laws on journalists and their sources have been well documented. But we can only wonder how many people will agree to participate in academic research if they are made fully aware of the real potential of being identified by investigators.

Who has access?

Metadata – or telecommunications data – is information held by telcos about communication from a digital device. This includes the phone numbers of people who call each other and how long they talk, as well as details on text messages (the address from which a message is sent and the time it’s sent).

Telcos are not allowed to disclose the “contents or substance of a communication”. But the metadata forms a key part of the investigative trail.

Since 2015, telecommunications and internet providers have been required to store metadata from phone calls and other digital communications for at least two years under the Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979.


Read more: Seven ways the government can make Australians safer – without compromising online privacy


Intelligence, policing and corruption bodies, the Department of Home Affairs, ASIC and the ACCC are agencies that are entitled to request this data. And some suggest many more government agencies at all three levels of government might be requesting metadata from telcos.

The weak protections offered to journalists won’t help researchers

A 2006 Australian Law Reform Commission inquiry into evidence laws raised the prospect of medical and social researchers being entitled to a confidentiality privilege for their research communications, but it was not implemented.

The only confidential relationship acknowledged by the metadata retention laws is the journalist-source relationship. This is where “journalist information warrants” must meet a certain threshold, reviewed in secret by an anonymous public interest advocate.

Should this protection be extended to researchers?

My colleagues and I made a recent submission to the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security examining the metadata retention laws. It focused on the fact journalism educators and journalism students might not qualify for even the minimal protections offered to professional journalists.

When agencies seek a warrant for information, the law requires:

the public interest in issuing the warrant outweighs the public interest in protecting the confidentiality of the identity of the source.

But the opaque scheme has been described by the journalism union as mere “cosmetic dressing” because the whole review process takes place in secret, by anonymous individuals, without the knowledge or legal representation of journalists or their sources. Even the journalists who have been subjected to the process remain unaware their data has been targeted.

Extending this protection to academic researchers in its current form would offer minimal comfort to confidential interviewees.


Read more: Police want to read encrypted messages, but they already have significant power to access our data


No warrant needed

Even encryption is no longer watertight as protective a strategy against agencies accessing metadata. Amendments last year introduced three levels of request agencies might make to telcos to de-encrypt data, starting with a simple voluntary “technical assistance request”.


Read more: Australians accept government surveillance, for now


There is no indication of the number of times agencies might have accessed researchers’ metadata because such detailed records are not published by the attorney-general or the ombudsman.

But the Commonwealth attorney-general finally revealed last month that during 2017-2018, 58 historical data authorisations were made under warrants issued to the AFP to get information from journalists.

For academic researchers, no such warrants are required. So, metadata requests about confidential interviewees would sit among the 300,000-plus requests made annually by agencies.

The issue is at least on the radar of some university research ethics committees. They take special precautions when approving confidential interviews in some circumstances, such as requiring researchers advise interviewees that absolute confidentiality might not be guaranteed.


Read more: How surveillance is wrecking journalist-source confidentiality


But there should be greater awareness of potential dangers that await their “confidential” interviewees who might have agreed to be interviewed without even contemplating the consequences.

Mark Pearson has received research funding from the Australian Research Council, the Commonwealth Government, and several other organisations and agencies. He has delivered media law training to several media organisations as a consultant.

Authors: Mark Pearson, Professor of Journalism and Social Media, Griffith Centre for Social and Cultural Research, Griffith University, Griffith University

Read more http://theconversation.com/australian-metadata-laws-put-confidential-interviews-at-risk-with-no-protections-for-research-121320

Better pay and more challenge: here's how to get our top students to become teachers

Relative to other careers, bright students who were surveyed didn't see teaching as coming with career challenges. www.shutterstock.comAustralia’s young high achievers are turning their backs o...

Peter Goss, School Education Program Director, Grattan Institute - avatar Peter Goss, School Education Program Director, Grattan Institute

Does anyone have a pad? TV is finally dismantling the period taboo

New attitudes show periods might finally be coming of age. July Prokopiv/ShutterstockLast week, menstrual pad brand Libra launched their Blood Normal commercial in Australia, running it during prime ...

Lara Owen, PhD Candidate, Monash University - avatar Lara Owen, PhD Candidate, Monash University

How doctors convinced the world the planet was worth fighting for

International Physicians for the Prevention of Nuclear War, which won the Nobel Peace Prize in 1985, is one example of doctors' involvement on the political stage. Wellcome Images/Wikimedia CommonsLas...

James Dunk, Research Fellow, University of Sydney - avatar James Dunk, Research Fellow, University of Sydney

After 2 festival deaths, the NSW government rushed through a new drug homicide crime. But it may do more harm than good

The first of its kind in Australia, the offence of 'drug supply causing death' carries a maximum 20 year sentence. ShutterstockAs the state election loomed last year, the NSW government rushed through...

Elyse Methven, Lecturer in Law, University of Technology Sydney - avatar Elyse Methven, Lecturer in Law, University of Technology Sydney

Voter turnout at New Zealand local elections keeps falling, but paying people to vote could backfire

Rather than encouraging people to become better citizens, rewards and fines can actually reduce peoples’ natural tendencies to do the right thing by others. from www.shutterstock.com, CC BY-NDLa...

Julia Talbot-Jones, Lecturer, Victoria University of Wellington - avatar Julia Talbot-Jones, Lecturer, Victoria University of Wellington

The digital human: the cyber version of humanity's quest for immortality

If it were possible to download the neural networks of a human brain, could we preserve a computer simulation of that person? from www.shutterstock.com, CC BY-NDImmortality has been a topic of discuss...

David Evans Bailey, PhD Researcher in Virtual Reality, Auckland University of Technology - avatar David Evans Bailey, PhD Researcher in Virtual Reality, Auckland University of Technology

Three ways to fix the problems caused by rezoning inner-city industrial land for mixed-use apartments

Show Works, based in the Melbourne suburb of Preston, makes dance floors, dance equipment and theatre scenery. Andrew Warren, used with permission, Author providedSince 2000, planning authorities in A...

Carl Grodach, Professor and Director of Urban Planning & Design, Monash University - avatar Carl Grodach, Professor and Director of Urban Planning & Design, Monash University

Interesting Ways to Have Fun Without Leaving Your House

Having fun isn’t synonymous to going out. This is what a lot of people should know if they’re looking to do fun things without leaving the comfort of their homes. The truth is that spending time...

News Company - avatar News Company

Become Independent and Install a Solar Power System in your Property

We are certainly living in a very exciting time, and when you consider the technological advances we have witnessed in the last 50 years, it really is amazing. In the 1960s, the Internet emerged and...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Amazon is on fire – here are 5 things you need to know

Huge fires are raging across multiple regions of the Amazon Basin. Guaira Maia/ISARecord fires are raging in Brazil’s Amazon rainforest, with more than 2,500 fires currently burning. They are ...

Danilo Ignacio de Urzedo, PhD candidate, University of Sydney - avatar Danilo Ignacio de Urzedo, PhD candidate, University of Sydney

It's not just athletes who get Achilles tendon pain, but exercising is the answer

Basketball fans around the world were recently sickened by the footage of NBA star Kevin Durant’s Achilles tendon rupturing during a game. But while many think it’s only elite athletes...

Sean Docking, Post-doctoral researcher, La Trobe University - avatar Sean Docking, Post-doctoral researcher, La Trobe University

Australia's energy woes will not be solved by reinforcing a monopoly

Australia's energy market has a logjam, Sean Davis/Flickr, CC BY-NC-SAThe possibility of blackouts affecting half of Victoria has attracted plenty of attention to a document once read only by industry...

Bruce Mountain, Director, Victoria Energy Policy Centre, Victoria University - avatar Bruce Mountain, Director, Victoria Energy Policy Centre, Victoria University

Tim Fischer had his blind spots, but he was an unsung champion of an Asian-facing Australia

Amid the tributes to former deputy prime minister Tim Fischer and the stories of his authenticity, courage and quirky interests – like trains and military history – what has struck me most...

Tim Harcourt, J.W. Nevile Fellow in Economics and host of The Airport Economist, UNSW - avatar Tim Harcourt, J.W. Nevile Fellow in Economics and host of The Airport Economist, UNSW

VIDEO: Michelle Grattan on Tim Fischer's legacy - and Scott Morrison's first year

Michelle Grattan talks about the sad news of the passing of former Deputy Prime Minister Tim Fischer with University of Canberra Vice-Chancellor Professor Deep Saini. They also discuss Scott Morrison&...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

Catastrophic Queensland floods killed 600,000 cattle and devastated native species

In February, about 600,000 cattle were killed by catastrophic flooding across north Queensland’s Carpentaria Gulf plains. The flood waters rose suddenly, forming a wall of water up to 70km wi...

Gabriel Crowley, Adjunct Principal Research Fellow, James Cook University - avatar Gabriel Crowley, Adjunct Principal Research Fellow, James Cook University

Four home traps that contribute to the gender pay gap

KPMG says Australia's gender pay gap declined from $3.05 an hour in 2014 to $2.43 in 2017. www.shutterstock.comAustralia’s gender pay gap is diminishing, says a new report, but some contributors...

Emma Willamson, Adjunct Senior Research Fellow, Monash University - avatar Emma Willamson, Adjunct Senior Research Fellow, Monash University

Australia wants to install military technology in Antarctica – here's why that's allowed

Technology, such as satellite systems, can be used for both military and scientific purposes. ShutterstockThis week, the ABC revealed that the Australian Defence Force wants to roll out military tech...

Tony Press, Adjunct Professor, Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, University of Tasmania - avatar Tony Press, Adjunct Professor, Institute for Marine and Antarctic Studies, University of Tasmania

Why some feminists oppose allowing people to choose their sex on birth certificates

Legislation in Victoria would allow people to change the sex on their birth certificates with just a declaration, not sex reassignment surgery. ShutterstockA bill currently before the Victorian parlia...

Holly Lawford-Smith, Senior Lecturer in Political Philosophy, University of Melbourne - avatar Holly Lawford-Smith, Senior Lecturer in Political Philosophy, University of Melbourne

Plants are going extinct up to 350 times faster than the historical norm

Plant extinctions have skyrocketed, driven in large part by land clearing and climate change. Graphic Node/Unsplash, CC BY-SAEarth is seeing an unprecedented loss of species, which some ecologists are...

Jaco Le Roux, Associate Professor, Macquarie University - avatar Jaco Le Roux, Associate Professor, Macquarie University

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company

LifeStyle

Interesting Ways to Have Fun Without Leaving Your House

Having fun isn’t synonymous to going out. This is what a lot of people should know if they’re ...

A Guide for Tenants

The cost of purchasing a home has been increasing, and the size of deposits needed, make buying pr...

Top ways for men to look after their skin

According to Jack Simmons, from Aboutmen, more and more men are taking pride in their appearance a...

Top 10 Caravan Storage Tips & Tricks

Taking caravan trips is a popular Aussie pastime, but if you have spent more than a few days in ...