• Written by Roberta Ryan, Professor, UTS Institute for Public Policy and Governance and UTS Centre for Local Government, University of Technology Sydney
Australians want greater housing choice, including affordable compact homes that are neither large detached houses nor multistorey apartments. Markus J/Shutterstock

Australians need greater housing diversity to meet their current and future housing needs. Yet increasing diversity, and meeting the need for more smaller dwellings in particular, has proved surprisingly difficult to achieve. Vested interests – both the big end of town and traditionalists seeking to preserve Australians’ suburban way of life – have come together in a rare alliance to argue against policies to deliver more diverse housing.

There are strong demographic drivers of the need for a more diverse range of housing in our cities. Not all current and future households want single standalone houses or multi-storey apartments.

Indeed, three recent surveys showed city dwellers are looking for housing diversity, particularly smaller houses such as terraces and semi-detached dwellings, in inner and middle suburbs. This demand comes from downsizers as well as families. We are seeing a clear recognition of the shortage of this stock.

There is strong community support for providing more housing choice in the areas where people already live. People as they approach retirement overwhelmingly want to stay in the same neighbourhood.

Read more: Becoming more urban: attitudes to medium-density living are changing in Sydney and Melbourne

Housing hasn’t kept up with changing needs

From about the 1980s, cities began to respond to the economic, social and environmental consequences of sprawl by promoting more compact urban forms and concentrating high-density housing in selected urban centres. However, new housing in Australian cities has typically been dominated by two categories: freestanding homes and apartments.

Attempts to introduce more diverse housing have met with fierce resistance from home owners in existing low-density suburbs. As a result, cities in Australia have some of the largest houses and lowest densities in the world.

And just on the horizon is a huge demographic bubble of older Australians, many living in these large detached houses. This means much of our housing stock is likely to be under-used.

Furthermore, lifestyles are changing, including greater workforce participation by women and ever-increasing commute times. These changes have made smaller, lower-maintenance houses in inner and middle suburbs, with good public transport, very desirable places to live.

Read more: We need more flexible housing for 21st-century lives

The ‘missing middle’ of housing supply

Despite these trends, our bigger cities offer limited variation in housing types. Australians mostly have a choice between single detached houses or high-density apartment living.

Take Sydney as an example. More than half of new homes built in the city are high-rise apartments. In 2018, 30,880 apartments were completed in Sydney, with another 194,000 in the pipeline.

Housing that is neither a freestanding house nor an apartment accounts for only 14% of housing approvals in Sydney. Only 5,390 such homes were approved in 2015-16. This is despite current council zoning and planning controls offering the potential for almost 280,000 of these dwellings.

Dwelling supply from high-density apartments and from greenfield land releases will continue to provide the most significant proportion of future housing requirements.

Read more: 'Children belong in the suburbs': with more families in apartments, such attitudes are changing

However, there is a compelling case for an increase in different housing types in established urban areas, especially in middle suburbs developed in post war years.

Between 1919 and 1962, fewer terrace houses were built as they fell out of favour. Homes on quarter-acre blocks were built across Australian cities, aided by the construction of train lines and then the arrival of cars and motorways. Later, when strata title laws were introduced, apartments were increasingly developed.

But this housing legacy no longer meets the needs of large sections of our population, both old and young. The variety of housing supply has not kept pace with changing household needs, particularly as household sizes have shrunk and housing costs have soared.

Singles and couple-only households are increasing, accounting for more than 50% of all household types in some cities. Average household size has fallen below 2.5 people from more than 3 at the start of the 1990s.

These trends are partly linked to an ageing population. By 2036 the number of the Australian population aged over 60 will have increased by 56%. More than one in seven people will be over 65.

Read more: Lack of housing choice frustrates would-be downsizers

The other fast-growing age segment in Australian cities is young people and young families. But, as house prices rise, home ownership levels for people in the 20-35 age group are falling.

Governments need to challenge vested interests

Housing stock other than multistorey apartments or larger suburban homes will provide more affordable homes for smaller households. Compact, well-designed houses on smaller land parcels are around 25% more affordable than detached houses (for newer or more recent stock) in the same neighbourhoods.

Yet providing this sort of housing stock still presents considerable challenges. Existing owners in middle-ring suburbs are concerned about change and loss of character. Councils face stiff opposition when they try to increase densities and introduce new housing stock.

The opposition often comes from people who have lived in these suburbs for a long time. This opposition is sometimes supported by the property sector, which perhaps fears this kind of stock could undermine demand for new high-rise apartments.

There are no powerful interest groups advocating for housing diversity because this market, in infill suburbs, is widely dispersed among individual householders.

Oregon has become the first US state to comprehensively bar local governments from imposing exclusive single-family residential zoning, and to open up almost all residential zones to low-density housing stock. The Oregon experience shows that, after many years of trying alternative approaches, state government action was required to achieve housing diversity against the arguments of local councils, residents and the property industry. Neighbourhoods with this diversity of housing are now among the state’s most desirable.

Roberta Ryan and Neil Selmon reviewed the NSW Low Rise Medium Density Housing Code for the NSW Minister for Planning and Public Spaces in July 2019.

Authors: Roberta Ryan, Professor, UTS Institute for Public Policy and Governance and UTS Centre for Local Government, University of Technology Sydney

Read more http://theconversation.com/people-want-and-need-more-housing-choice-its-about-time-governments-stood-up-to-deliver-it-122390

The best recipes for gin drink from around the world

Gin is a very interesting drink to explore. Gin is a surprisingly versatile drink when it comes to the flavor profile and can have different ranges of flavor profile when trying out different brands...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Most In-Demand Jobs for 2020

When choosing their career, a lot of people focus exclusively on the paycheck; however, this is definitely not all that matters. Whether or not a profession is in-demand will certainly affect the ...

Diana Smith - avatar Diana Smith

4 Ways Art and Creativity Raises Satisfied Children

Sydney is more than the Opera House, countless bars, and the harbour. Around it is the many suburbs that are excellent places to raise a family. From Hunters Hill to Gladesville, these areas offer...

News Company - avatar News Company

The best type of shoe to wear to a wedding

There are a hundred things that have to be sorted out before attending a wedding. Which dress to wear, which hairstyle to make, accessories and what shoes to wear. Choosing a perfect pair of shoes c...

News Company - avatar News Company

Seven things to consider before buying toys online

Technology has turned the world in a small global village. Your desired food is just a click away, and so is almost every other thing. E-shopping has rampantly gripped people in its web. People no l...

News Company - avatar News Company

'Slow-minded and bewildered': Donald Trump builds barriers to peace and prosperity

The US president “had no plan, no scheme, no constructive ideas whatever”, according to one of the world’s most influential economists. He was “in many respects, perhaps inev...

John Hawkins, Assistant Professor, School of Politics, Economics and Society, University of Canberra - avatar John Hawkins, Assistant Professor, School of Politics, Economics and Society, University of Canberra

What we learn from a fish that can change sex in just 10 days

The male bluehead wrasse defends his group of yellow females, one of whom has to step-up and take charge if he leaves. Kevin Bryant, Author providedThe bluehead wrasse is a fish that lives in small so...

Jenny Graves, Distinguished Professor of Genetics, La Trobe University - avatar Jenny Graves, Distinguished Professor of Genetics, La Trobe University

Family Values review: David Williamson's new uncomfortable, confronting play

The newest play from Australia's most prolific playwright sees David Williamson in vintage form. Brett Boardman/Griffin Theatre CompanyReview: Family Values, directed by Lee Lewis, Griffin Theatre Com...

Ian Maxwell, Associate Professor in Performance Studies, University of Sydney - avatar Ian Maxwell, Associate Professor in Performance Studies, University of Sydney

White, male and straight – how 30 years of Australia Day speeches leave most Australians out

Scott Morrison emphasised national unity in his Australia Day address last year, but this is not the message that everyone wants to hear. FacebookLast year on Australia Day, Prime Minister Scott Morri...

Nicholas Bromfield, Lecturer, University of Sydney - avatar Nicholas Bromfield, Lecturer, University of Sydney

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company