Viw Magazine

Men's Weekly

.

  • Written by Iain Walker, Professor of Psychology, University of Canberra

Last week, amid the cacophony of reactions to Greta Thunberg’s appearance before the United Nations Climate Action Summit, a group of self-proclaimed “prominent scientists” sent a registered letter to UN Secretary-General António Guterres. The letter, headed “There is no climate emergency”, urged Guterres to follow:

…a climate policy based on sound science, realistic economics and genuine concern for those harmed by costly but unnecessary attempts at mitigation.

The group, supported by 75 Australian business and industry figures, along with others around the world, obviously rejects the scientific consensus on climate change. But this missive displays remarkably different tactics to those previously used to stymie climate action.


Read more: Climate explained: why some people still think climate change isn't real


The language of climate change denial and inaction has transformed. Outright science denial has been replaced by efforts to reframe climate change as natural, and climate action as unwarranted.

However, this is just another way of rejecting the facts, and their implications for us. Denial can take many forms.

Shades of denial

The twin phenomena of denial and inaction are related to one another, at least in the context of climate change. They are also complex, both in the general sense of “complicated and intricate”, and in the technical psychological sense of “a group of repressed feelings and anxieties which together result in abnormal behaviour”.

In his book States of Denial, the late psychoanalytic sociologist Stanley Cohen described three forms of denial. Although his framework was developed from analysing genocide and other atrocities, it applies just as well to our individual and collective inaction in the face of the overwhelming scientific evidence of human-induced climate change.

The first form of denial is literal denial. It is the simple, conscious, outright rejection that something happened or is happening – that is, lying. One Nation senators Pauline Hanson and Malcolm Roberts, among others, have at one time or another maintained this position – outright denial that climate change is happening (though Senator Hanson now might accept climate change but denies any human contribution to it).

Interestingly, former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull yesterday blamed “climate change deniers” in his own government for blocking any attempt to deal with climate change, resulting paradoxically in higher energy prices today.


Read more: Misogyny, male rage and the words men use to describe Greta Thunberg


It is tempting to attribute outright denial to individual malice or stupidity, and that may occasionally be the case. More worrying and more insidious, though, is the social organisation of literal denial of climate change. There is plenty of evidence of clandestine, orchestrated lying by vested interests in industry. If anyone is looking for a conspiracy in climate change, this is it - not a collusion of thousands of scientists and major science organisations.

The second form of denial is interpretive denial. Here, people do not contest the facts, but interpret them in ways that distort their meaning or importance. For example, one might say climate change is just a natural fluctuation or greenhouse gas accumulation is a consequence, not a cause, of rising temperatures. This is what we saw in last week’s letter to the UN.

The most insidious form of denial

The third and most insidious form is implicatory denial. The facts of climate change are not denied, nor are they interpreted to be something else. What is denied or minimised are the psychological, political, and moral implications of the facts for us. We fail to accept responsibility for responding; we fail to act when the information says we should.

Of course, some are unable to respond, financially or otherwise, but for many, implicatory denial is a kind of dissociation. Ignoring the moral imperative to act is as damning a form of denial as any other, and arguably is much worse.

The treatment of Thunberg, and the vigour with which people push away reminders of that which they would rather not deal with, illustrate implicatory denial. We are almost all guilty, to some extent, of engaging in implicatory denial. In the case of climate change, implicatory denial allows us to use a reusable coffee cup, recycle our plastic or sometimes catch a bus, and thus to pretend to ourselves that we are doing our bit.

Almost none of us individually, or we as a nation, has acted as we ought on the science of climate change. But that does not mean we can’t change how we act in the future. Indeed, there are some recent indications that, as with literal denial, implicatory denial is becoming an increasingly untenable psychological position.

While it is tempting, and even cathartic, to mock the shrill responses to Thunberg from literal and interpretive deniers, we would do well to ponder our own inherent biases and irrational responses to climate change.

For instance, we tend to think we are doing more for the planet than those around us (and we can’t all be right). We also tend to think literal deniers are much more common in our society than they in fact are.


Read more: Extinction Rebellion protesters might be annoying. But they have a point


These are just two examples of common strategies we use to deny our own responsibility and culpability. They make us feel better about what little we actually do, or congratulate us for accepting the science. But they are ultimately self-defeating delusions. Instead of congratulating ourselves on agreeing with the basic scientific facts of climate change, we need to push ourselves to action.

Iain Walker's research has been supported through funding from the ARC, CSIRO, the Australian Federal Police, the University of Canberra, Murdoch University, the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission, and the WA Office of Multicultural interests.

Zoe Leviston's research has been supported through funding from Edith Cowan University and previously through CSIRO.

Authors: Iain Walker, Professor of Psychology, University of Canberra

Read more http://theconversation.com/there-are-three-types-of-climate-change-denier-and-most-of-us-are-at-least-one-124574

How Construction Law Firms in Melbourne Safeguard Complex Projects

Introduction From multi-storey developments to infrastructure upgrades, construction in Melbourne is thriving. Yet each project carries l...

The Ultimate Guide to Home Security Camera Laws in Australia

Security cameras are now one of the most common ways Australians protect their homes, families, and businesses. But before you install a C...

Ways Branded Apparel Boosts Team Morale & Business Image

Introduction Branded uniforms and apparel are often seen as a basic necessity, but they play a much bigger role in building company cultu...

The Rise of WordPress-Powered Mobile Applications

In the age of rapid digitalisation, companies are always on the lookout for new methods to reach their customers and provide end-to-end digi...

7 Ways Roller Shutters Perth Can Save You Money & Energy

Thinking about ways to cut down on your bills and make your home more comfortable in Perth? You're not alone! Many homeowners are looking fo...

Sydney Gets Fired Up: Fireball Whisky Launches ‘Motel Fireball Inn’

The number one shot in Australia (and the USA) is turning up the heat!  Fireball Whisky is bringing the party to Sydney with the launch...

Why Headless CMS Is Essential for Global B2B Sales Enablement

B2B selling is more global, digital and complex than ever. B2B buyers want accurate, timely and needs-based information no matter where th...

Top Tips for Successfully Completing Training and Passing Driving Tests

Learning to drive can feel exciting and a little overwhelming at the same time. Whether you’re preparing for your very first driving test ...

Why Location Still Rules in Real Estate

When people talk about real estate, the phrase location, location, location always comes up. It might sound like a cliché, but it’s still...

The Ultimate Guide to Renting: Landlord and Tenant Rights

Renting a property can be a smooth and rewarding experience when both landlords and tenants understand their rights and responsibilities. Cl...

The Pros and Cons of Renting vs. Owning a Home

Deciding between owning and renting a home is a huge financial choice a lot of people have to deal with in their lifetime. While homeownersh...

Innovative Ways to Showcase Your Products and Services Effectively

You don’t have to be in these waters to know that marketing has always been a game of attention. Attention is expensive, even more than go...

How to Choose the Right Real Estate Agent for You

Whether you’re buying or selling a property, having a real estate agent on your side can be a game-changer. They know the ins and outs of ...

Finding True Connection in the Rush of Modern Life

Life in major cities is full of opportunities, yet many residents find themselves feeling disconnected and isolated. Despite being surrounde...

Finding Balance: Fun, Safety, and Connection in Modern Nightlife

Modern nightlife has evolved into more than just dancing and music—it’s a cultural space where people seek entertainment, connection, an...

Essential Skills and Tips for First-Time Volunteers Abroad

So, you have decided to embark on a jubilant adventure of volunteering abroad? Congrats, you are in for a real treat! Not only that, but who...

Essential Considerations When Choosing a Family Home

Finding the right home for your family is one of the biggest and most important decisions you'll ever make. It's about more than just a buil...

Considerations When Renovating or Expanding Your Property

Renovating or expanding your property can be an exciting journey, offering the opportunity to tailor your home or investment to meet evolvin...

Elevating Your Social Life: Experiences Beyond the Ordinary

In a world where so much of our daily routine feels predictable, people are increasingly searching for experiences that add meaning to life...

Essential Gardening Accessories for a More Comfortable Outdoor Lifestyle

Gardening should be fun and relaxing, not a chore. Having the right things with you can make a huge difference. This guide will show you sim...