Viw Magazine

Men's Weekly

.

  • Written by Jemma Holt, Research Fellow/ Acting Executive Officer (Research), Tasmania Law Reform Institute, University of Tasmania
We can't stop jurors accessing the internet, but we can educate them and encourage self-regulation. from www.shutterstock.com

Juries are supposed to consider evidence without influence or bias from the outside world. However, the widespread access to and use of the internet and social media threatens to undermine this, with significant consequences for our criminal justice system and those within it.

Given courts cannot effectively police smart-phone use they must adapt to it. This week the Tasmania Law Reform Institute completed its year long inquiry into courts and the information age, and has recommendations as to how they can adapt.


Read more: Jurors and social media: is there a solution?


The right to a fair & unbiased trial by your peers

An accused person’s right to a fair trial is the most fundamental principle of our criminal justice system. It is a phrase that describes a system that affords an accused person many protections. That system relies on jurors being impartial and returning a verdict that is based solely on the evidence that is presented within the courtroom.

In the past this was readily easy to achieve. Juror communications during trial hours and even after them could be controlled. News about the trial was generally a local affair, and even when it attracted national attention, the journalists needed to be in the court’s jurisdiction to report, so they and their employers were subject to the court’s authority.

The shift in the way people access news, information and communications in the modern age has changed this reality.

Almost every Australian has access to the internet via their smartphone or other devices, social media use is habitual among much of our population, and the internet is a ubiquitous source of information for most people.

Jurors are no different – in fact, they represent the wider Australian community these statistics describe. While jurors’ smart phones are removed from them during trial, they cannot be before or after the trial period, nor at the beginning or end of the day. As a result jurors may intentionally, or simply by habit seek out or communicate information about the trial.


Read more: All about juries: why do we actually need them and can they get it 'wrong'?


Use and misuse of social media

Between 2018 and 2020 the Tasmanian Law Reform Institute conducted an inquiry into juror misuse of the internet and social media during trials. The institute concluded there is likely to be a high, but unquantifiable and undetectable level of misuse.

However, there is evidence across Australian jurisdictions that jurors have used their internet connected devices to:

  • research legal terms or concepts or other information relevant to the trial. A West Australian juror in a drug-related trial obtained information online about methylamphetamine production

  • research the accused, witnesses, victims, lawyers or the judge. Two South Australian jurors sitting in a blackmail trial against multiple defendants conducted online searches about the accused which disclosed past outlaw motorcycle gang affiliations

  • communicate with people involved in the trial. Multiple New South Wales jurors on a long-running fraud trial became Facebook friends, sharing posts such as a digitally altered photo of one of the jurors wearing a judge’s wig

  • publish material about the trial on the internet or social media. A NSW juror sitting in a sexual offending trial posted on Facebook the day before the guilty verdict was returned: “When a dog attacks a child it is put down. Shouldn’t we do the same with sex predators?” This post was accompanied with a photograph that showed images of rooms and implements by which lawful executions are carried out.

Misuse is under-reported. In those few instance where reports are made, fellow jurors, rather than court officers, tend to be the ones who raise the issue. Indeed, it is an important part of their role.

While jurors across Australia are currently told not to conduct online research, wilful disobedience is only part of the problem. It can also involve unintentional acts by jurors who believe they are doing the right thing.

For instance, jurors accessing online news, entertainment or social media sites can be passively influenced by information relevant to the trial. Jurors often misunderstand their role and conduct independent research in the genuine belief their actions are in the pursuit of “fairness” or discovering the truth.

What jurors see online could affect their choice in the courtroom. from www.shutterstock.com

Educate, inform & encourage self-regulation

The law reform institute ultimately concluded it is impossible for, and beyond the capacity of courts to completely police juror internet use. It has thus recommended not reforming the law, but rather strengthening and standardising juror education and directions. These recommendations are divided across two stages of jury selection, as part of an overall strategy:

  • pre-selection: prospective jurors should receive improved training and information about the role of the juror and the risks of internet use

  • post-selection: once a jury has been selected, judges need to explain to jurors what dangers arise from using the internet to access and publish on social media, seeking information about the case, parties, court officers, lawyers, and self-conducted research into legal concepts or sentences. The report has recommended the court adopt minimum standard directions, but also have the flexibility to make specific directions relevant to any particular trial.

The report recommended certain current practices and laws should remain unchanged, including:

  • removing phones from jurors while they are in court (even though the effect is limited it avoids juror distraction)

  • leaving contempt (punishment) laws in place for those jurors who intentionally ignore court training and directions. That might include monetary fines and, in severe cases, imprisonment.

This process is aimed at encouraging self-regulation among jurors, by educating them how to curtail their internet use and why it’s so important.


Read more: Trial by social media: why we need to properly educate juries


Jemma Holt receives funding from the Law Foundation of Tasmania.

Brendan Gogarty receives funding from Law Foundation of Tasmania.

Authors: Jemma Holt, Research Fellow/ Acting Executive Officer (Research), Tasmania Law Reform Institute, University of Tasmania

Read more http://theconversation.com/juries-need-to-be-told-how-theyre-allowed-to-use-the-internet-to-ensure-fair-trials-130127

Sydney Gets Fired Up: Fireball Whisky Launches ‘Motel Fireball Inn’

The number one shot in Australia (and the USA) is turning up the heat!  Fireball Whisky is bringing the party to Sydney with the launch...

Why Headless CMS Is Essential for Global B2B Sales Enablement

B2B selling is more global, digital and complex than ever. B2B buyers want accurate, timely and needs-based information no matter where th...

Top Tips for Successfully Completing Training and Passing Driving Tests

Learning to drive can feel exciting and a little overwhelming at the same time. Whether you’re preparing for your very first driving test ...

Why Location Still Rules in Real Estate

When people talk about real estate, the phrase location, location, location always comes up. It might sound like a cliché, but it’s still...

The Ultimate Guide to Renting: Landlord and Tenant Rights

Renting a property can be a smooth and rewarding experience when both landlords and tenants understand their rights and responsibilities. Cl...

The Pros and Cons of Renting vs. Owning a Home

Deciding between owning and renting a home is a huge financial choice a lot of people have to deal with in their lifetime. While homeownersh...

Innovative Ways to Showcase Your Products and Services Effectively

You don’t have to be in these waters to know that marketing has always been a game of attention. Attention is expensive, even more than go...

How to Choose the Right Real Estate Agent for You

Whether you’re buying or selling a property, having a real estate agent on your side can be a game-changer. They know the ins and outs of ...

Finding True Connection in the Rush of Modern Life

Life in major cities is full of opportunities, yet many residents find themselves feeling disconnected and isolated. Despite being surrounde...

Finding Balance: Fun, Safety, and Connection in Modern Nightlife

Modern nightlife has evolved into more than just dancing and music—it’s a cultural space where people seek entertainment, connection, an...

Essential Skills and Tips for First-Time Volunteers Abroad

So, you have decided to embark on a jubilant adventure of volunteering abroad? Congrats, you are in for a real treat! Not only that, but who...

Essential Considerations When Choosing a Family Home

Finding the right home for your family is one of the biggest and most important decisions you'll ever make. It's about more than just a buil...

Considerations When Renovating or Expanding Your Property

Renovating or expanding your property can be an exciting journey, offering the opportunity to tailor your home or investment to meet evolvin...

Elevating Your Social Life: Experiences Beyond the Ordinary

In a world where so much of our daily routine feels predictable, people are increasingly searching for experiences that add meaning to life...

Essential Gardening Accessories for a More Comfortable Outdoor Lifestyle

Gardening should be fun and relaxing, not a chore. Having the right things with you can make a huge difference. This guide will show you sim...

Best Practices for Managing High-Volume Material Movement in Industrial Settings

If there is one thing that is the backbone of a large industry, that’s undoubtedly the ideal management of material movement. For any high...

8 Best Things to Do Near Ballarat, VIC

Ballarat isn’t just a city with a gold rush past—it’s a hub of adventure, history, nature, and amazing local experiences. Whether youâ...

Different Approach Proves Better Results in Addiction Counselling

Addiction is one of the biggest issues for relationships. It not only puts strain on the one struggling, but the people around them too. E...

5 Timber Decking Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands

Dreaming of relaxing on your brand-new deck, soaking up the Aussie sunshine? A timber deck can be a fantastic addition to any home, creati...

7 Ways Disability Services Can Transform Lives

Imagine a life where you feel empowered, supported, and truly connected to your community. For individuals living with disabilities, this ...