Viw Magazine

The Property Pack

  • Written by Dustin Marshall, Professor, Marine Evolutionary Ecology, Monash University
An adult _Plectropomus leopardus_ from the Whitsundays. (Credit to David Wachenfeld, Triggerfish Images),

One hectare of ocean in which fishing is not allowed (a marine protected area) produces at least five times the amount of fish as an equivalent unprotected hectare, according to new research published today.

This outsized effect means marine protected areas, or MPAs, are more valuable than we previously thought for conservation and increasing fishing catches in nearby areas.

Previous research has found the number of offspring from a fish increases exponentially as they grow larger, a disparity that had not been taken into account in earlier modelling of fish populations. By revising this basic assumption, the true value of MPAs is clearer.

Read more: Protecting not-so-wild places helps biodiversity

Marine Protected Areas

Marine protected areas are ocean areas where human activity is restricted and at their best are “no take” zones, where removing animals and plants is banned. Fish populations within these areas can grow with limited human interference and potentially “spill-over” to replenish fished populations outside.

Obviously MPAs are designed to protect ecological communities, but scientists have long hoped they can play another role: contributing to the replenishment and maintenance of species that are targeted by fisheries.

Wild fisheries globally are under intense pressure and the size fish catches have levelled off or declined despite an ever-increasing fishing effort.

Yet fishers remain sceptical that any spillover will offset the loss of fishing grounds, and the role of MPAs in fisheries remains contentious. A key issue is the number of offspring that fish inside MPAs produce. If their fecundity is similar to that of fish outside the MPA, then obviously there will be no benefit and only costs to fishers.

Read more: More fish, more fishing: why strategic marine park placement is a win-win

Big fish have far more babies

Traditional models assume that fish reproductive output is proportional to mass, that is, doubling the mass of a fish doubles its reproductive output. Thus, the size of fish within a population is assumed to be less important than the total biomass when calculating population growth.

But a paper recently published in Science demonstrated this assumption is incorrect for 95% of fish species: larger fish actually have disproportionately higher reproductive outputs. That means doubling a fish’s mass more than doubles its reproductive output.

When we feed this newly revised assumption into models of fish reproduction, predictions about the value of MPAs change dramatically.

Author provided

Fish are, on average, 25% longer inside protected areas than outside. This doesn’t sound like much, but it translates into a big difference in reproductive output – an MPA fish produces almost 3 times more offspring on average. This, coupled with higher fish populations because of the no-take rule means MPAs produce between 5 and 200 times (depending on the species) more offspring per unit area than unprotected areas.

Put another way, one hectare of MPA is worth at least 5 hectares of unprotected area in terms of the number of offspring produced.

We have to remember though, just because MPAs produce disproportionately more offspring it doesn’t necessarily mean they enhance fisheries yields.

For protected areas to increase catch sizes, offspring need to move to fished areas. To calculate fisheries yields, we need to model – among other things – larval dispersal between protected and unprotected areas. This information is only available for a few species.

We explored the consequences of disproportionate reproduction for fisheries yields with and without MPAs for one iconic fish, the coral trout on the Great Barrier Reef. This is one of the few species for which we had data for most of the key parameters, including decent estimates of larval dispersal and how connected different populations are.

No-take protected areas increased the amount of common coral trout caught in nearby areas by 12%. Paul Asman and Jill Lenoble/Flickr, CC BY

We found MPAs do in fact enhance yields to fisheries when disproportionate reproduction is included in relatively realistic models of fish populations. For the coral trout, we saw a roughly 12% increase in tonnes of caught fish.

There are two lessons here. First, a fivefold increase in the production of eggs inside MPAs results in only modest increases in yield. This is because limited dispersal and higher death rates in the protected areas dampen the benefits.

Read more: Caught on camera: Ancient Greenland sharks

However the exciting second lesson is these results suggest MPAs are not in conflict with the interests of fishers, as is often argued.

While MPAs restrict access to an entire population of fish, fishers still benefit from from their disproportionate affect on fish numbers. MPAs are a rare win-win strategy.

It’s unclear whether our results will hold for all species. What’s more, these effects rely on strict no-take rules being well-enforced, otherwise the essential differences in the sizes of fish will never be established.

We think that the value of MPAs as a fisheries management tool has been systematically underestimated. Including disproportionate reproduction in our assessments of MPAs should correct this view and partly resolve the debate about their value. Well-designed networks of MPAs could increase much-needed yields from wild-caught fish.

Dustin Marshall receives funding from Australian Research Council.

Liz Morris does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors: Dustin Marshall, Professor, Marine Evolutionary Ecology, Monash University

Read more

Safety First: Tips for Selecting a Safe Bunk Bed Mattress

Ensuring the safety of bunk beds is paramount, and the mattress plays a crucial role in creating a secure sleeping environment for child...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

How Cash for Car Companies Works in Brisbane? A Beginner's Guide

If you've ever wondered about those signs that say "Cash for Cars," you're not alone. Selling a car has traditionally involved a series of...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Practical Tips and Creative Choices

Maybe you've just completed your undergraduate thesis, or maybe you're further on in your career and you're looking into research paper pr...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

How Do Heat Pump Hot Water Systems Save Energy?

Power bills in Brisbane are soaring, leaving homeowners grasping for ways to reel in their expenses. One of the biggest culprits behind th...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

How do Solar Hot Water Systems Save Energy?

Are your sky-high electricity bills giving you the shivers? You're not alone. They've become a big problem for many Brisbane homeowners, a...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Upgrading Your Turn: The Best Energy Plans and Master Removalists in Sutherland Shire

Moving to another house is a critical life altering situation, and guaranteeing a smooth change includes key preparation and independent d...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Double-glazing Sustainable Living and Environmental Edge

In relation to the modern world that is evolving faster than ever, the selection, regarding windows in addition to doors, has been deeme...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

The Essential Guide to Designing a Business Logo

In the digital age, a compelling business logo is crucial for brand recognition and establishing a professional identity. A well-designed ...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Understanding TMV (Thermal Mixing Valve) in Plumbing

In the realm of plumbing and water systems, the term "TMV", or Thermal Mixing Valve, plays a critical role in ensuring safety, comfort, an...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Embracing Australian Culture and Landscape through Poster Art

Australia is a land of extraordinary diversity, teeming with unique wildlife, bustling cities, and awe-inspiring natural landscapes. From ...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Painting 101 – Nursery Room Guide

Waiting for your child to be born into this world is an exciting time, especially the first time around. You still have no idea what to expe...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Unlocking the Power of Cloud Storage: A Comprehensive Guide

As much as technology is advancing, the need to have secure and better fast technology storage options is also advancing. In this articl...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

The Future of Crypto Trading: BitGPT's Intelligent Bot.

The world of crypto trading has undergone a rapid evolution in recent years. As blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies continue to gai...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Five Must-Visit Destinations for Your Vacation

In a world teeming with an abundance of awe-inspiring destinations, the task of selecting the perfect vacation spot can often feel like a ...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Embracing Sustainability: The Future of Home Furniture

In a world increasingly conscious of its environmental footprint, sustainable home furniture is not just a trend but a necessity. This mov...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Understanding the Importance of Wheel Alignment for Vehicle Performance

In the realm of automobiles, the term "wheel alignment" might not always be a topic of everyday conversation. However, its significance in...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

How to Perfect Your Roast Lamb: Tips for Juiciness

Roasting lamb is an art that combines tradition with the skill to create a dish that's tender, succulent, and bursting with flavour. The k...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

Elevate Your Kitchen Aesthetics with ASW Company's Glass Splashbacks

Introduction The kitchen, often considered the heart of a home, is a space where functionality meets aesthetics. From culinary adventures...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

The Versatile Fungus: Exploring the Many Uses of Mushrooms

Mushrooms are a diverse and fascinating group of organisms that have been an integral part of human culture and cuisine for centuries. Th...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine

32 Secs: Unleashing Adrenaline with the Ultimate Traffic Rider APK

Introduction If you're a fan of high-speed motorcycle racing and crave the excitement of weaving through traffic, then 32 Secs: Traffic R...

Viw Magazine - avatar Viw Magazine