Viw Magazine

  • Written by Adrian Bauman, Sesquicentenary Professor, Public Health, University of Sydney

If you noticed headlines recently suggesting smoking could protect against COVID-19, you might have been surprised.

After all, we know smoking is bad for our health. It’s a leading risk factor for heart disease, lung disease and many cancers. Smoking also reduces our immunity, and makes us more susceptible to respiratory infections including pneumonia.

And smokers touch their mouth and face more, a risk for COVID-19 infection.

Initial observational findings suggested a history of smoking increased the risk of poor outcomes in COVID-19 patients, as the World Health Organisation and other bodies have identified.

But a recent paper which examined smoking rates among COVID-19 patients in a French hospital hypothesised smoking might make people less susceptible to COVID-19 infection.

So what can we make of this?

Read more: Smoking increases your coronavirus risk. There's never been a better time to quit

What the study did

This study was a cross-sectional survey where the researchers assessed the exposure (smoking) and the outcome (COVID-19) at the same time. This type of research design can’t prove the exposure causes the outcome – only that there may be an association.

There were two groups included in the study – 343 inpatients treated for COVID-19 from February 28 to March 30, and 139 outpatients treated from March 23 to April 9. Among other data collected, participants were asked whether they were current smokers.

The researchers compared smoking rates in both groups with smoking rates in the general French population.

The results

The study found 4.4% of inpatients and 5.3% of outpatients with COVID-19 were smokers, after adjusting for differences in age and sex.

This was only a fraction of the prevalence seen in the general French population. Some 25.4% reportedly smoked daily in 2018.

The authors asserted:

current smokers have a very much lower probability of developing symptomatic or severe SARS-CoV-2 infection as compared to the general population.

The finding of lower rates of smokers among COVID-19 cases has been more recently described elsewhere, in a rapid review of 28 studies on smoking in COVID-19 patients from various countries.

Read more: Why do more men die from coronavirus than women?

The authors of the French study suggest the mechanism behind the protective effects of smoking could be found in nicotine.

SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, gains entry into human cells by latching onto protein receptors called ACE2, which are found on certain cells’ surfaces.

The researchers have proposed nicotine attaches to the ACE2 receptors, thereby preventing the virus from attaching and potentially reducing the amount of virus that can get into a person’s lung cells.

The researchers are now planning to test their hypothesis in a randomised trial involving nicotine patches; though the trial is still awaiting approval from French health authorities.

So how should we interpret the results?

These counterintuitive results may be due to several biases, so let’s explore some alternative explanations.

First is what we call “selection bias”. The hospital patients may be less likely to be daily smokers than the general population. For example, health-care workers and those with existing chronic conditions were disproportionately represented in the inpatient sample – both of these groups usually show lower prevalence of current smoking.

Further, around 60% of the hospitalised patients in the study were ex-smokers (similar to the national prevalence). Some may have given up smoking very recently in response to the WHO declaring smoking as a risk factor for COVID-19. But they were classified as non-daily smokers in the study.

We can identify several biases in the study. Shutterstock

Second is what we call “social desirability bias”. COVID-19 patients may be more likely to deny smoking when asked about their smoking status in hospital, wanting to be seen by medical professionals as doing the right thing.

And data collection may have been incomplete for behavioural questions in busy hospitals overwhelmed by COVID-19 cases.

Finally, it’s important to note this paper has not yet been peer-reviewed.

Taken together, although there appears to be an association between smoking and COVID-19 in these hospital-based samples, there’s no evidence of a causal relationship – that is, that smoking prevents COVID-19.

Read more: Drug use may increase the risk of coronavirus. Here's how to reduce the harms

Lots of research at pandemic speed

We must acknowledge this research has been conducted at “pandemic speed”, much faster than usual research time frames.

Normally it would be months between submission and publication – but in this case the researchers completed their observations and had the research published online within the same month.

An unintended consequence of the early release of research is that it may provoke undue community hope or belief in unproven treatments.

French authorities had to limit sales of nicotine treatments to avoid stockpiling after this study was published.

Read more: The smoke from autumn burn-offs could make coronavirus symptoms worse. It’s not worth the risk

We saw a similar phenomenon recently with the drug hydroxychloroquine, where supplies ran out for those who needed them after politicians proclaimed it as a cure for COVID-19.

So right now we need to put in extra effort to make sure early evidence is not misinterpreted or overstated.

As for the role of smoking in COVID-19 – this link requires substantially more research and critical appraisal. Because overall, smoking still kills. – Adrian Bauman, Melody Ding and Leah Shepherd

Blind peer review

On the whole, this Research Check represents a fair and balanced account of the study. The alternative explanations for the observation of low smoking status prevalence among the French hospital sample provided are possible.

One plausible explanation is error in recording smoking status. There is evidence of under-reporting and inaccurate reporting of smoking status within hospital samples, in general.

It’s unclear from the study what method was used to collect smoking status data. The authors simply state patients were “asked” and “data were collected in the context of care”. It’s important to know who asked the smoking status questions, what questions were asked, when they were asked, and what record keeping system was used.

Given clinical smoking status record keeping may not capture all smokers accurately, a better comparison would be to compare the 2020 data with pre-COVID-19 hospital patient data, rather than general population data which may have asked different questions. – Billie Bonevski

Research Checks interrogate newly published studies and how they’re reported in the media. The analysis is undertaken by one or more academics not involved with the study, and reviewed by another, to make sure it’s accurate.

Authors: Adrian Bauman, Sesquicentenary Professor, Public Health, University of Sydney

Read more

Dominique Grubisa Shares her Secrets to Property Investing Success

Investing is the way to go nowadays – and property investment is quite popular in this area. However, we all know that investments com...

Dominique Grubisa - avatar Dominique Grubisa

How To Travel in a Quarantined World During Pandemic

If you travel for business or pleasure, it’s as if you are living in an ever-changing world. For Australians and New Zealanders, the t...

Merissa Moore - avatar Merissa Moore

10 Steps How To Start Your Life Over

Arranging care for the elderly is a challenge. With all the advancements in technology, children moving away for work or careers, and al...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

6 Reasons to Visit Jakarta

When you think about a trip to Indonesia, the first things that come to your mind are the beautiful sandy beaches spread across many islan...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

How to Choose a Hotel? Tips and Recommendations

Imagine having a vacation soon. You have chosen the country you have long wanted to travel to, selected dates and tickets. You can alrea...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

How Much Does Dog Training Cost?

You have decided to get a dog and whether it is a puppy or an adult rescue dog from a shelter, you will have to invest in some dog training...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Refurbished Samsung Galaxy S Series vs. Note Series

Samsung’s Note series devices have always come after the S-series devices, each with a different target audience. The note series device...

Zedd Salem - avatar Zedd Salem

Picking the right Smartphone: 7 Features to Consider

Do you want to upgrade your smartphone? Or do you want to buy a smartphone for the first time? Choosing a suitable smartphone isn't an easy ...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Which laptop should I get? 5 Top Features to Consider

The market is flooded with numerous laptops you can choose from. It is, therefore, a daunting task to pick a reliable laptop for your work. ...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Redefining Retail Marketing Support Services

For 20 years Retex has been an intermediary for the retail industry, offering free membership and saving its members over 100 million dollar...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Facebook Views: A Trophy For Influencers

Facebook is a mega popular American social media platform created by Mark Zuckerberg and his fellow Harvard university roommates. It has a...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Importance of Likes In Increasing YouTube Subscribers To Your Channel

YouTube is a website exceptionally designed to upload videos on the internet. In comparison to other search engines, it is the second-la...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo


Any ring that is given to a lady by a gentleman is a symbol of love, devotion, and an agreement to cherish love during the engagement even...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Top Signs That Your Business Needs a Managed Service Provider

Do you have an efficient network? Do you keep on coping with IT issues? It may be the best time to seek help from outside. Managed servi...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

What Is The Meaning Of A Smart Home?

A home that consists of automated and internet appliances and devices directly connected to a specific mobile application is referred to...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Why purchase your coffee online

Technological developments have led to revolutions in all industries. Coffee is a beverage liked by most of the population for its refresh...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

How To Maintain Healthy Eyes

Eyes play a very critical role in our lives. They enable us to easily move from one place to another and enjoy seeing the beautiful things...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Tips for choosing the right web Development Company

Regardless of the type of business you operate, you need a website to help you be more competitive in the market. Venturing into your fi...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Understanding Fibroids Symptoms

Muscular tumors that form and grow in the wall of the womb or uterus are called Fibroids. They are sometimes referred to as leiomyoma or...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Why Opt for Ducted Air Conditioning?

Many people when they are considering options for keeping their homes cool during the hot months with air conditioning, consider ducted ai...

NewsCo - avatar NewsCo

Writers Wanted

News Co Media

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion