Viw Magazine

The Times


.

Mr Morrison, I lost my home to bushfire. Your thoughts and prayers are not enough

  • Written by: Janet Stanley, Associate professor/Principal Research Fellow, Melbourne Sustainable Society Institute, University of Melbourne
Prime Minister Scott Morrison inspecting a burnt-out property in the Gold Coast hinterland in September 2019. Mr Morrison has offered "thoughts and prayers" to those affected by the fires. Dave Hunt/AAP

Fires of unprecedented number and ferocity are today raging in New South Wales and Queensland. Residents in some regions woke to news that the fire danger was “catastrophic”. Rural fire chief Shane Fitzsimmons was blunt when he explained what that means: “It’s where people die.”

I lost my home in Victoria’s 1983 Macedon bushfires. I know sympathy and financial assistance for those in the midst of the crisis is important. However, when political leaders such as Prime Minister Scott Morrison offer their “thoughts and prayers”, it’s hard to read this as anything but disingenuous.

Scientists and meteorologists have for years warned of more frequent and extreme bushfires as climate change worsens. Their messages have been met by policy inertia. Nationals leader Michael McCormack on Monday went so far as to dismiss those who link bushfires to global warming as “raving inner-city lunatics”.

If the Morrison government seriously wanted fewer Australians to experience a bushfire crisis, it would use the current situation to galvanise public sentiment, shift the political agenda, and make meaningful inroads into emissions reduction.

A growing danger

Catastrophic fire danger has been forecast for Greater Sydney, Hunter and Illawarra-Shoalhaven residents. These are the worst possible conditions, under which officials have warned fires are almost impossible to control and homes will burn.

The World Meteorological Organisation said in February that the four years to 2018 were the hottest on record, in a clear sign of climate change “associated with record atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases”.


Read more: Drought and climate change were the kindling, and now the east coast is ablaze


Bushfires are not directly attributable to climate change. However, the fast-warming climate is making bushfires more frequent and intense.

In Australia, weekly bushfire frequencies increased by 40% in the five years to 2016, particularly during summer months, suggesting a serious climatic shift.

The Northern Hemisphere is also suffering. Research released earlier this year found that California’s annual wildfire extent had increased fivefold since the 1970s. This was very likely driven by drying forest fuels under human‐induced warming.

Letter boxes burn north of Los Angeles, California, on October 30. ETIENNE LAURENT/EPA

The mountain of irrefutable evidence linking global warming to bushfires makes the federal government’s failure to act - or even talk about the problem - extremely hard to explain. Of course, worsening bushfires are not the only signal that climate change has arrived.

The Murray-Darling Basin, like much of Australia, is in the midst of drought. It reportedly averaged 887 millimetres of rain over the 34 months to the end of October - the lowest on record. Climate change cannot be directly blamed for causing a specific drought, but makes a drought more severe.

Meanwhile, Australia’s national emissions are rising year-on-year. In particular, emissions from fossil fuels and industry are now 7% above 2005 levels.


Read more: The science of drought is complex but the message on climate change is clear


But it’s not too late to turn the ship around. The current bushfire emergency is an opportune moment to join the dots and prepare to implement significant climate change policies.

Experts say such a plan would include setting a credible pathway to net zero emissions and defining clear policy routes to renewable energy, such as replacing existing coal generators with clean energy by 2035.

Climate costs and the benefits of avoiding climate change should be integrated into mainstream decision-making across government and business.

Bayswatercoal-fired power station, near Muswellbrook in the Hunter region of NSW. DAN HIMBRECHTS/AAP

Prevention is better than cure

Even if the Morrison government tackled climate change with gusto tomorrow, the reality is that the problem has already taken hold. And as former NSW Fire and Rescue Commissioner Greg Mullins this week warned, “we are not adequately prepared” for the monster fires that will result.

The Productivity Commission has warned that bushfire prevention is largely overlooked and severely under-resourced. It said government natural disaster funding arrangements are “prone to cost shifting, ad hoc responses and short-term political opportunism”.

Crucially, the commission said governments “overinvest in post-disaster reconstruction and underinvest in mitigation that would limit the impact of natural disasters in the first place”.


Read more: It's only October, so what's with all these bushfires? New research explains it


It called for a major overhaul and whole-of-system approach to fire prevention and suppression. This would involve representation from multiple community, government and community sectors, and needs to be well-resourced.

Untapped opportunities for bushfire prevention abound. For example, there is little recognition that at least 90% of bushfires are accidentally or deliberately started by people. More research into this area is needed.

Residents look on as a fire threatens homes at Belmont, NSW, in August 2019. Darren Pateman/AAP

More than sympathy

My first-hand experience of bushfire was traumatic. I was a young mother and the trauma was particularly felt by my children. It challenges your personal identity and security, which is significantly defined by your “home” and living location.

My direct experience leaves me unable to comprehend why politicians would not take every opportunity through climate change policy to reduce ongoing and increasing risks to the Australian population.

When a bushfire emergency is current, it affords the opportunity to better understand the many personal, community and environmental costs of climate change - and galvanise politicians to act.

Janet Stanley does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors: Janet Stanley, Associate professor/Principal Research Fellow, Melbourne Sustainable Society Institute, University of Melbourne

Read more http://theconversation.com/mr-morrison-i-lost-my-home-to-bushfire-your-thoughts-and-prayers-are-not-enough-126754

Google Updates 2026: A Practical SEO Checklist for Australian Businesses

  Google updates 2026 are on the minds of businesses that rely on search to reach customers, whether they sell software, gadgets, games or ...

What to Add to Your Weekly Diet for Stronger, Glossier Strands

Achieving thick, vibrant hair requires more than just high-quality shampoos and topical serums. Real hair vitality starts from within, drive...

How to Reverse Sun Damage and Restore Moisture to Your Hair

Australia's harsh summer sun takes a heavy toll on our tresses, leaving them dry, brittle, and prone to breakage. While many of us remembe...

How to Build a Daily Hair Care Routine for Stronger, Shinier Strands

Achieving lustrous, resilient hair requires consistent daily care rather than occasional expensive treatments. While advanced clinical opt...

What to Do for Fine Hair to Instantly Boost Volume

Fine, flat hair often feels like a daily styling challenge, leaving many searching for ways to inject life and bounce into limp locks. While...

Why Melbourne Buyers Choose Loose Sapphires for Custom Engagement Rings

An engagement ring often starts as a finished image: a stone in a setting, photographed from the perfect angle. But some couples prefer to...

How to Clear a Deceased Estate: A Gentle, Practical Guide for Sydney Families

Losing a loved one is hard enough. Then, often within weeks, families are faced with the task of sorting through a lifetime of belongings...

NBN Not Working? Common Causes and What to Do Before Calling a Technician

There's never a good time for the internet to drop out. It always seems to happen in the middle of a work call, halfway through a movie or...

Off-Road Caravan for Sale: What to Look for Before You Buy

Buying a caravan is a significant investment. So, it is worth looking beyond the price tag and choosing a dealer that understands what you...

How Split Corrugated Conduit And Solar Conduit Support Better Cable Protection

Why Cable Protection Starts With The Application Wiring can encounter movement, abrasion, moisture, heat and physical contact depending o...

Can You Increase Your Income with Duplex and Dual Occupancy Builds?

A dual occupancy build is when 2 independent homes are constructed on a single block of land. They can either share a wall, as with a dupl...

Choosing Shutters and Blinds for Different Rooms in a Melbourne Home

Start With the Function of Each Room For homeowners comparing window coverings, shutters and blinds can be assessed by looking at light c...

How Property Conveyancing In Melbourne Helps Buyers And Sellers Navigate A Property Transaction

What Property Conveyancing Involves In Melbourne Buying or selling a property involves more than signing a contract and arranging finance...

Planning Bottle Label Printing for Different Product Applications

Bottle Branding Across Different Industries When businesses need packaging or printed containers developed for a particular application, ...

Why Corten Is Used for Distinctive Outdoor Steel Applications

Understand the weathering process Outdoor steel can serve both a functional and visual purpose, particularly when a project calls for a w...

Trailers in Melbourne: How to Choose the Right Box Trailer for Your Needs

Comparing Trailer Types in Melbourne The right trailer depends on what needs to be transported and how the trailer will be used. Buyers com...

How a Livestock Identification and Traceability System Supports Smarter Cattle Management

Why Identification Matters Beyond Basic Herd Records Modern cattle management depends on having reliable information about where animals ...

Choosing A Locksmith Melbourne For Residential Security Needs

Why The Right Locksmith Matters Finding a reliable locksmith Melbourne homeowners can contact involves more than locating someone who can...

Planning Custom Waste Solutions Around Business Requirements

Starting With the Business Waste Profile Businesses do not all generate the same type or volume of waste, so the arrangement used to manage...

Choosing a Year 11 Chemistry Tutor for Consistent Subject Support

Identify the Main Reason for Seeking Support Before choosing a year 11 Chemistry tutor, students can identify what is currently making Chem...

How A Sliding Screen Door Can Enhance Large Architectural Openings

A Practical Layer For Large Openings A sliding screen door can provide a practical screening layer across an opening while allowing occupan...

Common Mistakes Brisbane Business Owners Make When Entering Commercial Agreements

Commercial agreements are an essential part of running any successful business. Whether working with suppliers, customers, business partners...

How Uniform Wholesales Help Organisations Manage Staff Clothing

Why Wholesale Uniform Supply Matters To Growing Organisations When an organisation needs uniforms for a team, buying individual garments fr...

What to Consider Before Choosing an Illuminated Mirror

An LED mirror combines a reflective surface with integrated illumination, making it useful in bathrooms, dressing areas and other spaces whe...