• Written by Bernadette McSherry, Foundation Director, Melbourne Social Equity Institute, University of Melbourne
Shutterstock

In 2018, the Victorian Ombudsman, Deborah Glass, delivered a report about “the saddest case” she had ever seen.

A 39-year-old woman with a developmental disorder had been locked in her prison cell for up to 23 hours a day for more than 18 months. The woman had been charged with breaching an intervention order (a charge which was later dropped) and resisting arrest.

The Ombudsman commented this was not an isolated incident. Last year, The Age reported a 49-year-old wheelchair user with an acquired brain injury had spent three years in prison with no end date in sight after being charged with assault.


Read more: How Aboriginal women with disabilities are set on a path into the criminal justice system


What unites the circumstances of these two people with disabilities is both had been found “unfit to plead”. This finding may lead to indefinite detention and/or supervision despite no finding of guilt.

But there are viable alternatives. Criminal justice liaison officers, disability support workers and communication assistants can help people with cognitive disability understand the criminal process so they can choose to plead guilty or not guilty.

What are ‘unfitness to plead’ laws?

Unfitness to plead laws are based on the idea people accused of crimes should not be put on trial if they can’t understand the legal process and the charges against them. The main aim is to avoid unfair trials.

Once charged with a crime, they may not be released or left unsupervised because of concerns about community protection, yet they can’t be convicted or acquitted because holding a trial is considered unfair.

Unfitness to plead rulings mean people with conditions that affect their ability to learn, process, communicate and remember information can end up in detention indefinitely.


Read more: 'Unfit to plead': why does the law jail those with intellectual disabilities indefinitely?


There are too many people with cognitive disability in prison

In a previous article, I outlined how people with cognitive disability form a disproportionately large cohort of prisoners.

A 2011 report for the Victorian Department of Justice estimated 42% of male prisoners and 33% of female prisoners in Victoria had an acquired brain injury, compared to about 2% of the general population.

Indefinite detention for people with cognitive disability and/or mental illnesses can worsen existing health conditions. Shuttershock

An infringement on their liberty

The Victorian Law Reform Commission estimated findings of unfit to plead or not guilty on the grounds of mental impairment make up less than 1% of the total cases that result in a sentence or supervision order in the higher courts.

While those affected by unfitness to plead laws may form a small subset of prisoners with cognitive disability and/or mental illness, data isn’t kept in Victoria on how often fitness to plead issues are raised in relation to summary offences (less serious offences). There’s also no national database to make comparisons about unfitness to plead cases across states and territories.

Extensive data indicates Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people with disabilities face added disadvantage in the criminal justice system. One 2012 report found 11 of 33 people deemed unfit to plead or “unsound of mind” in Western Australia were Indigenous. Further, all nine men on indefinite supervision orders in the Northern Territory found unfit to plead in 2012 were Indigenous.


Read more: Supporting, not imprisoning, Aboriginal people with disabilities could save millions


Efforts to provide support

In addition to law reforms, several initiatives are under way to support people who may be found unfit to plead navigate the criminal justice system.

The Australian Law Reform Commission recommended communication assistants and support people for them.

In October 2019, the Council of Australian Governments Disability Reform Council agreed the National Disability Insurance Agency should introduce justice liaison officers to support NDIS participants in youth and adult justice systems.

The NDIS is still developing the scheme, but it has the potential to help people with cognitive disability accused of a crime understand the trial process and in turn avoid findings of unfitness to plead.

The disability royal commission will look into unfit to plead laws. Shuttershock

There are several resources to support people with acquired brain injury and their supporters navigate the criminal justice system.

My colleagues and I developed a support program with three community legal centres in the Northern Territory, New South Wales and Victoria in 2017 which participants evaluated highly. This model could be cost-effective.

The disability royal commission

The disability royal commission has released an issues paper on criminal justice and people with disabilities which reflects on a number of issues raised in this article.

The commission is seeking submissions on what supports can help keep people with disabilities out of the criminal justice system or stay safe within the system.


Read more: Caring for ex-prisoners under the NDIS would save money and lives


Bernadette McSherry receives funding from the Australian Research Council. The Unfitness to Plead project was funded by a National Disability Research and Development Grant.

Authors: Bernadette McSherry, Foundation Director, Melbourne Social Equity Institute, University of Melbourne

Read more https://theconversation.com/people-with-cognitive-disability-shouldnt-be-in-prison-because-theyre-unfit-to-plead-there-are-alternatives-131295

Carpet Cleaning Tips

After work, the best feeling is to get home, your haven, where you can find peace and calm. But when you take a glance at your carpet, your heart shatters into pieces. The grime, dirt, and is it all...

News Company - avatar News Company

All Australians will be able to access telehealth under new $1.1 billion coronavirus program

Scott Morrison will unveil on Sunday a $1.1 billion set of measures to make Medicare telehealth services generally available during the coronavirus pandemic and to support mental health, domestic viol...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

How much more expensive is a two storey home?

The idea of adding a second storey to your home is exhilarating. Imagine, more living space, more bedrooms, more bathrooms, and a significant bump on the resale value of your home! For families, ha...

Digital 360 - avatar Digital 360

Parents, These FAQs Will Help You Prep for Childcare in Australia

If you’re a new immigrant in Australia, perhaps you have plenty of questions about childhood education. What school should you pick, or what’s the best age for them to attend school? To help you...

Darren Cunningham - avatar Darren Cunningham

Hotel quarantine for returning Aussies and 'hibernation' assistance for businesses

All Australians arriving from overseas will be quarantined in hotels or other facilities under strict supervision for a fortnight, under the latest crackdown in the battle against the coronavirus.Anno...

Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra - avatar Michelle Grattan, Professorial Fellow, University of Canberra

how sharing your data could help in New Zealand's level 4 lockdown

New Zealand and much of the world is now under an unprecedented lockdown. Public health experts say this is the best way to suppress the spread of the virus. But how long will such a lockdown be socia...

Jon MacKay, Lecturer, Business Analytics, University of Auckland - avatar Jon MacKay, Lecturer, Business Analytics, University of Auckland

What is orthohantavirus? The virus many are Googling (but you really don't need to worry about)

ShutterstockAccording to Google Trends, the top globally trending topic this week is “orthohantavirus”, as spurious sites claim it’s the next pandemic on the horizon.Take it from me:...

Allen Cheng, Professor in Infectious Diseases Epidemiology, Monash University - avatar Allen Cheng, Professor in Infectious Diseases Epidemiology, Monash University

MyGov's ill-timed meltdown could have been avoided with 'elastic computing'

DAN PELED/AAPThese past few weeks have shown the brittleness of Australia’s online systems. It’s not surprising the federal government’s traditionally slow-moving IT systems are buck...

Erica Mealy, Lecturer in Computer Science, University of the Sunshine Coast - avatar Erica Mealy, Lecturer in Computer Science, University of the Sunshine Coast

Why New Zealand’s coronavirus cases will keep rising for weeks, even in level 4 lockdown

ShutterstockThe number of New Zealanders testing positive for COVID-19 will continue to rise despite the strict conditions of the four-week lockdown that began this week. As of today, there are 368 ca...

Arindam Basu, Associate Professor, Epidemiology and Environmental Health, University of Canterbury - avatar Arindam Basu, Associate Professor, Epidemiology and Environmental Health, University of Canterbury

Sick and Tired of Your Dead End Job? Try Teaching!

Tired of the same old grind at the office? Want an opportunity to impact lives both in your community and around the world? Do you love to travel and have new experiences? Teaching English is the perfect job for you! All you need is a willingness to ...

News Company - avatar News Company

The Impact of an Aging Population in Australia

There’s an issue on the horizon that Australia needs to prepare for. The portion of elderly citizens that make up the country’s overall population is increasing, and we might not have the infrastructure in place to support this. Australians h...

News Company - avatar News Company

CBD



News Company Media Core

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion