Viw Magazine

  • Written by Piers Dunstan, Principal Research Scientist, CSIRO

There’s no denying the grandeur and allure of a nature reserve or marine protected area. The concept is easy to understand: limit human activity there and marine ecosystems will thrive.

But while the number of marine protected areas is increasing, so too is the number of threatened species, and the health of marine ecosystems is in decline.

Why? Our research shows it’s because marine protected areas are often placed where there’s already low human activity, rather than in places with high biodiversity that need it most.

Not where they should be

Many parts of the world’s protected areas, in both terrestrial and marine environments, are placed in locations with no form of manageable human activity or development occurring, such as fishing or infrastructure. These places are often remote, such as in the centres of oceans.

Read more: Protected marine areas seem a good idea – but they may have insidious political effects

And where marine protected areas have been increasing, they’re placed where pressures cannot be managed, such as areas where there is increased ocean acidification or dispersed pollution.

Limestone islands in the Coral Triangle. The marine protected areas. Shutterstock

But biodiversity is often highest in the places with human activity – we use these locations in the ocean to generate income and livelihoods, from tourism to fishing. This includes coastal areas in the tropics, such as the Coral Triangle (across six countries including Indonesia, the Philippines and Malaysia), which has almost 2,000 marine protected areas, yet is also home to one of the largest shipping routes in the world and high fishing activity.

Read more: Why seagrass in Indonesia's marine protected areas is still under threat

What’s more, many marine industries are already regulated through licences and quotas, so it’s hard to establish a new marine protected area that adds a different type of management on top of what already exists.

This leaves us with an important paradox: the places where biodiversity is under the most pressure are also the places humanity is most reluctant to relinquish, due to their social or economic value. Because of those values, people and industry resist changes to behaviour, leaving governments to try to find solutions that avoid conflict.

Lessons from the fishing industry

How can we resolve the paradox of marine protected areas? A strategy used in the fishing industry may show the way.

Fisheries have had experience in going beyond the limits of sustainability and then stepping back, changing their approach to managing species and ecosystems for better sustainability, while still protecting economic, social and environmental values.

Read more: Marine parks and fishery management: what's the best way to protect fish?

In the past, many of the world’s fisheries regularly exceeded the sustainable limit of catches, and many species such as southern bluefin tuna declined significantly in number. But strong rules around how a fishery should operate mean declines have since been reversed.

Changes to fishery management have reversed population declines in southern bluefin tuna. Shutterstock

So how did they do it? In recent decades, many of the world’s large-scale fisheries implemented formal “harvest strategies”. These strategies can flip downward trends of marine species in places not designated a marine protected area.

Harvest strategies have three steps. First is pre-agreed monitoring of species and ecosystems by fishers, regulators and other stakeholders. Second, regulators and scientists assess their impact on the species and ecosystems. And last, all stakeholders agree to put management measures in place to improve the status of the monitored species and ecosystems.

These measures may include changing how fishing is done or how much is done. It’s a commonsense strategy that’s delivered successful results with many fished species either recovering or recovered.

Read more: Protecting not-so-wild places helps biodiversity

In Australia, the federal government introduced a formal harvest strategy policy to manage fisheries in 2007. It was evaluated in 2014, and the report found many (but not all) fish stocks are no longer overfished. This includes species such as orange roughy and southern bluefin tuna in Australia, which were overfished but are no longer so.

But unfortunately, this positive trend has not been replicated for biodiversity hit by the combinations of other human activities such as coastal development, transport, oil and gas extraction and marine debris.

A consistent strategy

We need to adapt the experience from fisheries and apply a single, formal, transparent and agreed biodiversity strategy that outlines sustainable management objectives for the places we can’t put marine protected areas.

This would look like a harvest strategy, but be applied more broadly to threatened species and ecosystems. What might be sustainable from a single species point of view as used in the fisheries might not sustainable for multiple species.

Read more: Tropical fisheries: does limiting international trade protect local people and marine life?

This would mean for our threatened species, we would be monitoring their status, assessing whether the total population was changing and agreeing on when and how we would change the way that they are impacted.

Such a strategy would also allow monitoring of whole marine ecosystems, even when information is limited. Information on trends in species and ecosystems often exists, but is hidden as commercial-in-confidence or kept privately within government, research or commercial organisations.

Looking ahead

Still, a lack of data shouldn’t limit decision making. Experience in fisheries without much data shows even rules of thumb can be effective management tools. Rules of thumb can include simple measures like gear restrictions or spatial or temporal closures that don’t change through time.

Moving forward, all stakeholders need to agree to implement the key parts of harvest strategies for all marine places with high biodiversity that aren’t protected. This will complement existing marine protected area networks without limiting economic activity, while also delivering social and environmental outcomes that support human well-being.

Our marine ecosystems provide fish, enjoyment, resources and and simple beauty. They must survive for generations to come.

Authors: Piers Dunstan, Principal Research Scientist, CSIRO

Read more https://theconversation.com/why-marine-protected-areas-are-often-not-where-they-should-be-133076

Hammertoe Correction Procedures

Hammertoe is a rather common condition of the foot that causes the toe to turn downward.  It’s a deformity that can affect any toe of...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

The best kitchen tiles

In the market, there are various options available for kitchen flooring. One of the options includes the use of tiles. The homeowners need...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

7 Commercial Refrigeration Maintenance Tips to Extend Longevity

As essential as a commercial refrigerator is to your establishment, its maintenance is even more critical. Periodic maintenance is necessa...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

4 Relationship Problems & How to Solve them

Unlike in books and movies, it is pretty common to run into problems in a relationship. In fact, a large part of making a relationship w...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

5 steps to the perfect smokey eye makeup

A smokey eye is one of the most classic makeup looks in beauty history. From old Hollywood glam to modern red carpet looks, the smokey eye...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

5 natural beauty swaps for happier, healthier skin

It’s a sad fact that some of the most common beauty products found in your bathroom or makeup bag could be causing you more harm than good...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Car Finance Solutions for the Self-Employed

You jump many hurdles without guaranteeing your eligibility when applying for a car loan when you're self-employed or as a small busines...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

The importance of real estate’s economic role will only be amplified

Virtual tours are working and in instances where one-on-one COVID-safe inspections  are taking place by private appointment, the conversi...

Tim McKibbin, CEO, Real Estate Institute of NSW - avatar Tim McKibbin, CEO, Real Estate Institute of NSW

Koala launches new mattress range

From the makers of Australia’s most-loved mattress comes the brand spanking new mattress range: the new Koala Mattress, the new Koala ...

Kaylah Farrugia - avatar Kaylah Farrugia

EPL 2021-2022 and PDC World Darts Championship 2021: What’s In Store for Online Betting?

The Premier League 2020-2021 season has been one of the best and most entertaining editions of the competition for EPL fans worldwide. We ...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Why You Should Purchase Coffee Online in Australia

Australia is a land of coffee and Aussies love to drink coffee that tastes like coffee. They are known to be specific in quality coffee ...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Top 3 Techniques for controlling Possums in Australia

Possums may look adorable and cuddly, but they are extremely destructive, particularly when they get into your yard and move into your h...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Kayak Tour Guide For Beginners and Experienced in Sydney Harbour

When you visit Sydney, there are so many things to do and see, but you particularly want to see the iconic Sydney Harbour Bridge and the...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

The Best Business Ideas for Kids This Year

As ridiculous as it may sound, today’s kids have the ability to handle businesses. There are affordable business skills resources, techn...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Smart Pet Gadgets

We cannot be with our pets all the time, much less monitor their activities when we are away. The good news is that there are smart pet ga...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

6 Reasons Why Chocolate For Wedding Favours Is An All Time Favourite

Everyone loves chocolates (if you don’t; well, you’re missing out on one of the best things in life!) and there’s no reason why so...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

The custom face sock trend blowing up on Tik Tok & Instagram

With father’s day coming up, custom face socks have become a new gift trend. And it’s impressive how this custom face sock trend is ...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

5 Common Signs Of A Faulty Plumbing System

Plumbing is one of those things many don’t seem to think about until it’s too late. Although some plumbing issues may be solved by a plu...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

What You Need to Know Before Buying Off Road Campers

Thinking of buying off road campers? Not sure where to start? This article outlines four crucial things you need to consider before buyi...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

5 Reasons Why Your Company Should Use Facebook Advertising

Facebook is by far the most popularly spread social media platform worldwide, and provides business all over the world with immense busi...

NewsServices.com - avatar NewsServices.com

Writers Wanted



NewsServices.com

Content & Technology Connecting Global Audiences

More Information - Less Opinion