Viw Magazine

The Times


.

We looked at the health star rating of 20,000 foods and this is what we found

  • Written by: Alexandra Jones, Research Fellow (Food Policy and Law), George Institute for Global Health
We looked at the health star rating of 20,000 foods and this is what we found

As you read this, health officials are busy finalising the government’s review of the health star rating system on packaged foods.

One of the issues the review is looking at is whether the system, which has been voluntary in Australia and New Zealand since its launch in 2014, should become mandatory.

This is something public health and consumer groups have called for, but the food industry has opposed.

Our new research, which looked at health star ratings of 20,000 packaged foods, shows why mandatory health stars on all packaged food is needed.

We found less than half of all eligible foods carried them, and those that did were skewed towards foods with higher ratings.

Read more: Why the Australasian Health Star Rating needs major changes to make it work

Remind me, what is the health star rating?

The health star system rates products from 0.5 to 5.0 stars to help guide consumers toward healthier choices when browsing the supermarket shelves. When comparing similar products, the general idea is the higher the star rating, the healthier the food.

The health star rating lets you compare similar packaged foods to make healthier choices (Australian Government Department of Health).

However, the government’s review is meant to address criticism the food industry has “gamed” the system by exploiting loopholes in scoring criteria to allow some products high in sugar and salt to still score relatively highly.

While much attention has been directed towards closing these loopholes, public health and consumer groups would also like to see mandatory labelling.

Here’s what we did and what we found

We looked at health stars on packaged food in Australia between 2014 and 2019. We used the FoodSwitch database, which contains information about the labelling and nutrition of packaged food.

Every year, FoodSwitch is updated by photographing labels of all packaged foods and beverages in four large supermarkets in metropolitan Sydney. That’s a total of about 20,000 unique products.

For each year in this study, we recorded whether a product was displaying a health star rating and its value.

Read more: Essays on health: how food companies can sneak bias into scientific research

Where a product was not showing stars on the pack, we calculated how that product would rate using available nutrition information and applying the government’s calculator.

This gave us an idea of what information manufacturers were not yet providing consumers.

We also looked at the manufacturer of each product, and flagged whether they were represented on the committee overseeing implementation of the health stars system.

Voluntary use remains disappointing

We found uptake of food star ratings has increased steadily over the past five years. But only about 41% of eligible products carried one.

Retailers Coles, Woolworths and Aldi labelled their own private label brands, accounting for about 56% of all health star ratings. Despite this leadership, these retailers were not involved in the implementation committee.

However, members of the industry group the Australian Food and Grocery Council — involved in developing health stars and represented on the implementation committee — were responsible for only 29% of total uptake.

Read more: Fat nation: the rise and fall of obesity on the political agenda

Selective use, on healthier products

Perhaps unsurprisingly with voluntary labelling, health stars were more likely to appear on products with higher ratings. More than three-quarters of all stars were on products rated 3.0 or higher.

With a few exceptions, including McCain Foods, Coles and Woolworths, nearly all companies were more likely to show stars on their higher-scoring products.

We found significant differences between the average rating of products displaying the health star rating, and those made by the same manufacturer not showing a health star rating.

For example, Nestlé showed stars on its Uncle Toby’s breakfast cereals where they scored an average 3.9 stars. But the company did not provide the star logo on its confectionery range, which received an average 1.4 stars.

A voluntary system puts profits before health

Our results illustrate the limits of commercial goodwill in applying health stars voluntarily.

Selective use allows the food industry to market its products as healthy but denies consumers the chance to make meaningful comparisons between products.

In particular, the voluntary system limits consumers’ ability to identify and avoid less healthy foods.

With the government review set to be finalised in mid-July, our work supports arguments for an improved health star rating system to be made mandatory to ensure the system works for consumers, not just food companies.

Read more: Supermarkets put junk food on special twice as often as healthy food, and that's a problem

Here’s what needs to happen next

Making health stars mandatory will take time. However, health officials must commit now to a concrete and public plan to proceed down this path by a specific date in the likely event that uptake remains patchy.

Over the same period the health stars system has been operating, Australian manufacturers have implemented new requirements for mandatory country of origin labelling.

If we’re willing to use regulation to provide consumers more information about where their food comes from, we should be doing the same to provide more information about how healthy their food is too.

Authors: Alexandra Jones, Research Fellow (Food Policy and Law), George Institute for Global Health

Read more https://theconversation.com/we-looked-at-the-health-star-rating-of-20-000-foods-and-this-is-what-we-found-141453

Buying Your First Home in Sydney? The Mortgage Decisions That Could Affect Your Next Property

Buying your first home in Sydney involves more than finding a property you like and securing a mortgage. The decisions you make during your ...

New Brisbane Dads Embracing Weekly Baby Classes for Fun and Bonding

If you think baby classes are only for mums and their little ones, think again! New dads across Australia are embracing the benefits of at...

Turn a Compatible Backyard Pool into an Endless Swimming Lane—Without the Renovation Headache

For many Australian homeowners, a backyard pool is the centrepiece of summer living. Yet when it comes to regular swimming for fitness, ma...

Choosing Materials for Melbourne Kitchens and Bathrooms: A Climate and Lifestyle Guide

Melbourne has a reputation for weather that moves through four seasons in a single afternoon. For homeowners planning a renovation, that r...

Steel Frame Installation Timelines: What Melbourne Builders Can Expect From Design to Lock Up

Timelines are the quiet battleground of every residential project in Melbourne. Clients want fixed completion dates, finance brokers want ...

Asbestos Removalist Melbourne: What to Expect From a Professional Service

Before the Removal Begins If asbestos is suspected in a property, knowing what to expect from an asbestos removalist Melbourne service can ...

Cash for Cars Melbourne: A Practical Guide to Selling Your Vehicle

Selling an unwanted vehicle can take time when you need to organise advertising, answer enquiries and arrange inspections. Cash for cars M...

Selecting an Industrial Air Compressor for a Processing Facility

Compressed air can be an important utility in many industrial environments, supporting equipment and processes that require a reliable sou...

Tradesman Trailers: What to Look For When Buying a Work Trailer

For electricians, plumbers, builders, landscapers and other professionals, tradesman trailers provide a dedicated way to transport tools, ...

Emergency Locksmith Service: What to Do When You Need Urgent Help

Being locked out or discovering a damaged lock can interrupt your plans and create an immediate access or security concern. An Emergency L...

How a WooCommerce Website Designer Can Build a More Practical Online Store

A successful online store should be built around the way a business actually operates. A WooCommerce website designer can begin by consideri...

Understanding SMSF Setup and the Steps Involved

SMSF Setup is an important decision for people considering whether a self-managed super fund suits their retirement planning needs. An SMS...

Choosing a Dentist in Melbourne Patients Can Rely On

Finding a suitable Dentist Melbourne patients can visit with confidence starts with understanding their needs, concerns and priorities. Wh...

How Does Election Printing Melbourne Help Campaigns Communicate with Voters?

Why Is Election Printing in Melbourne an Important in Campaign Communication? An election campaign has a precise goal: to connect and commu...

Understanding Different Types of Packaging Supplies for Industrial and Commercial Applications

What Are the Main Types of Packaging Supplies Used by Businesses? In every industry, packaging supplies play an important role in protectin...

The Rights of an Employee as Per an Employment Lawyer in Melbourne

Understanding your rights at work can help you make informed decisions when questions or disagreements arise during employment. From pay and...

Why Professional Duct Cleaning Matters for a Cleaner Indoor Environment

A ducted heating or cooling system moves air through a network of return air ducts, individual duct lines and other components. Over time...

Choose the Right Battery Tray and Bash Plates for 4WD Protection

Driving a four-wheel drive on rough tracks can expose important components to rocks, ruts and debris. Preparing a vehicle for these conditio...

Brisbane’s Subdivision Rush Causes Concern Around Strata Survey Delays

To increase the housing supply across Brisbane, Queensland has put sweeping legislative changes into effect. As a result, residential prop...

First Trip to the USA? Phone and Data Tips Before You Board

The first hour in an American airport can be busier than the flight. You might need to book a ride from LAX, message a hotel in Manhattan ...

Caravan Dealers in Sydney and Melbourne Report Fuel Efficiency Back as Top Selling Point

Economic pressures are mounting as fuel prices continue to fluctuate; household budgets have never been tighter. As a result, caravan dealer...

Why a Child's Foot Is Meant to Change Shape as They Grow

Most children under three have flat feet, and most develop an arch by around age six, according to the Royal Children's Hospital in Melbou...

Workplace Safety Essentials Every Australian Employer Should Know

Safety is one of those topics that sends some business owners reaching for the snooze button. It conjures images of thick policy manuals, en...

A Beginner's Guide to Australia's Favourite Asian Comfort Foods

There is a particular kind of Australian childhood memory that involves a fish and chip shop, a paper bag and a deep-fried dim sim with a ge...

hacklink esim českoHerabetTrBetvpnfree books downloadzlibrarySahabetstreameastnon gamstopBetimselçuksportsgrandpashabet girişgrandpashabet girişdinamobetbetimStreamEastsohbet hattıxspintaraftarium24CrackStreamsholiganbetseo ajansıyurtdışı turseo danışmanlığıseo uzmanıgrandpashabet girişstreameastseo hizmetijojobetgrandpashabetjojobetviagra 100 mg fiyatjojobetjojobetcasibommy gift cardstreameastdeneme bonusu veren siteler 2026casibom