Viw Magazine

The Times


.

Four common debt traps: payday loans, consumer leases, blackmail securities and credit 'management'

  • Written by: Saurav Dutta, Harjinder Singh & Nigar Sultana
Businesses are structuring their lending practices to exploit loopholes in consumer credit laws Shutterstock

From Shakespeare’s Shylock to Dickens’ Ebenezer Scrooge to HBO’s Tony Soprano, characters who lend out money at exorbitant interest rates are unsavoury.

So what should we think of businesses that deliberately target the poorest and most vulnerable for corporate profits?

There has been significant growth in the unregulated small-loan market, aimed at people likely to be in financial stress. Concern about the problem led to an Australian Senate select committee inquiry into financial products targeted at people at risk of financial hardship.


Read more: What 1,100 Australians told us about the experience of living with debt they can't repay


It found plenty to report on, with businesses structuring their lending practices to exploit loopholes in consumer credit laws and to avoid regulation. Charging fees instead of interest is one example.

Below is a snapshot of four common lending practices identified in the inquiry’s final report. The practices may be legal but they all carry the high potential to make your financial situation worse, and ensnare you in a debt trap from which it is hard to escape.

1. The payday loan

Payday loans are advertised as short-term loans to tide you over until your next payday. They can be up to A$2,000. The payback time is between 16 days and 12 months.

Lenders are not allowed to charge interest but can charge fees, including an establishment fee of up to 20% and a monthly fee of up to 4% of the amount loaned.

If you don’t pay back the money in time, the costs escalate with default fees.

Most payday loans are “small amount credit contracts” (SACC), with three companies – Cash Converters, Money3 and Nimble – dominating the market.


Read more: Four reasons payday lending will still flourish despite Nimble's $1.5m penalty


In 2016, Cash Converters had to refund $10.8 million to customers for failing to make reasonable inquiries into their income and expenses. In 2018, it settled a class action for $16.4 million for having charged customers an effective annual interest rate of more than 400% on one-month loans.

But it is not necessarily the worst offender. The Senate inquiry’s report singles out one company, Cigno Loans (previously Teleloans), for allegedly appearing “to have structured its operations specifically to avoid regulation”, so it can charge fees that exceed the legal caps.

If you are on a low income and need money for essential goods or services, a better option is the federal No Interest Loans Scheme (NILS), which provides loans of up to $1,500 for 12 to 18 months with no interest charges or fees.

2. The consumer lease

A consumer lease is a contract that lets you rent an item for a period of time, usually between one and four years. You make regular rental payments until the term of the lease finishes.

This can be appealing because the regular payments are very low. But the length of the lease and terms of the contract end up making renting an item a very expensive option.

The Senate inquiry report notes that while consumer leases are subject to responsible lending obligations, unlike small amount credit contracts there is no cap on the maximum cost of a lease, and you will invariably pay more than the cost of buying and owning an item outright.

The report refers to a 2015 study by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission. The study involved Centrelink recipients leasing goods. Half paid more than five times the retail price of the goods. In one case leasing a clothes dryer for two years effectively cost 884% in interest.


Read more: Loan shark regulators need a lesson in behavioural economics


Consumer lease companies disproportionately profit from those on low incomes. The Senate inquiry heard about the the number of leases being paid through Centrepay, the direct debit service for Centrelink recipients.

Thorn Group, owner of Radio Rentals, told the inquiry 52% of its consumer-leasing customers paid via Centrepay. About A$600 million was paid through Centrepay for consumer leases in 2108.

ASIC’s rent vs buy calculator can help you work out the cost of consumer lease and whether a better option is available.

3. The blackmail security

Lenders sometimes earmark a borrower’s asset as a guarantee for the loan. If the debtor defaults, the lender takes the asset in compensation. Normally, the asset should be of higher value than the loan amount, to cover the debt if the the debtor ever defaults.

However, a lender might choose an asset with a lower value, because it is critical to the borrower’s livelihood. A car or work tools are two examples. The intention is to ensure the borrower prioritises repaying the loan over other expenses. Should you be unable to pay back the loan for some reason, losing an asset critical to earning an income will push you into greater financial hardship.

Because the practice is regarded as coercive, so-called blackmail securities are prohibited on loans lower than $2,000. The Senate inquiry report notes concern that some lenders appear to circumvent this restriction by lending more than $2,000.

So don’t assume generosity or oversight is the reason a lender offers you a bigger loan or to take as security an asset worth less. Think very carefully about the consequences if you can’t repay the loan.

4. The credit ‘manager’

If you’ve gotten into debt and ended up with a bad credit rating, credit repair services offer help with fixing your credit history or managing your debts.

These services may be legitimate businesses or non-profit community services. But there has been an alarming growth in unregulated debt negotiation and debt management services, charging exorbitant and hidden fees for minimal services. The fees and contract structures may be deliberately complex to obscure the costs.


Read more: Debt agreements and how to avoid unnecessary debt traps


According to the Senate inquiry report: “On the evidence provided to the committee in submissions and public hearings, these services rarely improve a consumer’s financial position. The charges for the debt management services increase their debt, and often consumers are referred to inappropriate remedies which may be expensive and cause lasting damage. The committee heard many case studies to this effect.”

ASIC recommends seeking help from free services first. You can find one through its MoneySmart website here.

Social obligation

Most people would agree we want a society that protects the most vulnerable. That includes having laws and regulations to protect the financially vulnerable.


Read more: There are serious problems with the concept of 'financial literacy'


The growth of financial services that target those most at risk of financial hardship suggests government and industry should take seriously the Senate inquiry’s recommendations.

The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Authors:

Saurav Dutta, Head of School at the School of Accounting, Curtin University

Harjinder Singh
Senior lecturer, Curtin University
 
Nigar Sultana
Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Business and Law, Curtin University

Read more http://theconversation.com/four-common-debt-traps-payday-loans-consumer-leases-blackmail-securities-and-credit-management-113564

Buying Your First Home in Sydney? The Mortgage Decisions That Could Affect Your Next Property

Buying your first home in Sydney involves more than finding a property you like and securing a mortgage. The decisions you make during your ...

New Brisbane Dads Embracing Weekly Baby Classes for Fun and Bonding

If you think baby classes are only for mums and their little ones, think again! New dads across Australia are embracing the benefits of at...

Turn a Compatible Backyard Pool into an Endless Swimming Lane—Without the Renovation Headache

For many Australian homeowners, a backyard pool is the centrepiece of summer living. Yet when it comes to regular swimming for fitness, ma...

Choosing Materials for Melbourne Kitchens and Bathrooms: A Climate and Lifestyle Guide

Melbourne has a reputation for weather that moves through four seasons in a single afternoon. For homeowners planning a renovation, that r...

Steel Frame Installation Timelines: What Melbourne Builders Can Expect From Design to Lock Up

Timelines are the quiet battleground of every residential project in Melbourne. Clients want fixed completion dates, finance brokers want ...

Asbestos Removalist Melbourne: What to Expect From a Professional Service

Before the Removal Begins If asbestos is suspected in a property, knowing what to expect from an asbestos removalist Melbourne service can ...

Cash for Cars Melbourne: A Practical Guide to Selling Your Vehicle

Selling an unwanted vehicle can take time when you need to organise advertising, answer enquiries and arrange inspections. Cash for cars M...

Selecting an Industrial Air Compressor for a Processing Facility

Compressed air can be an important utility in many industrial environments, supporting equipment and processes that require a reliable sou...

Tradesman Trailers: What to Look For When Buying a Work Trailer

For electricians, plumbers, builders, landscapers and other professionals, tradesman trailers provide a dedicated way to transport tools, ...

Emergency Locksmith Service: What to Do When You Need Urgent Help

Being locked out or discovering a damaged lock can interrupt your plans and create an immediate access or security concern. An Emergency L...

How a WooCommerce Website Designer Can Build a More Practical Online Store

A successful online store should be built around the way a business actually operates. A WooCommerce website designer can begin by consideri...

Understanding SMSF Setup and the Steps Involved

SMSF Setup is an important decision for people considering whether a self-managed super fund suits their retirement planning needs. An SMS...

Choosing a Dentist in Melbourne Patients Can Rely On

Finding a suitable Dentist Melbourne patients can visit with confidence starts with understanding their needs, concerns and priorities. Wh...

How Does Election Printing Melbourne Help Campaigns Communicate with Voters?

Why Is Election Printing in Melbourne an Important in Campaign Communication? An election campaign has a precise goal: to connect and commu...

Understanding Different Types of Packaging Supplies for Industrial and Commercial Applications

What Are the Main Types of Packaging Supplies Used by Businesses? In every industry, packaging supplies play an important role in protectin...

The Rights of an Employee as Per an Employment Lawyer in Melbourne

Understanding your rights at work can help you make informed decisions when questions or disagreements arise during employment. From pay and...

Why Professional Duct Cleaning Matters for a Cleaner Indoor Environment

A ducted heating or cooling system moves air through a network of return air ducts, individual duct lines and other components. Over time...

Choose the Right Battery Tray and Bash Plates for 4WD Protection

Driving a four-wheel drive on rough tracks can expose important components to rocks, ruts and debris. Preparing a vehicle for these conditio...

Brisbane’s Subdivision Rush Causes Concern Around Strata Survey Delays

To increase the housing supply across Brisbane, Queensland has put sweeping legislative changes into effect. As a result, residential prop...

First Trip to the USA? Phone and Data Tips Before You Board

The first hour in an American airport can be busier than the flight. You might need to book a ride from LAX, message a hotel in Manhattan ...

Caravan Dealers in Sydney and Melbourne Report Fuel Efficiency Back as Top Selling Point

Economic pressures are mounting as fuel prices continue to fluctuate; household budgets have never been tighter. As a result, caravan dealer...

Why a Child's Foot Is Meant to Change Shape as They Grow

Most children under three have flat feet, and most develop an arch by around age six, according to the Royal Children's Hospital in Melbou...

Workplace Safety Essentials Every Australian Employer Should Know

Safety is one of those topics that sends some business owners reaching for the snooze button. It conjures images of thick policy manuals, en...

A Beginner's Guide to Australia's Favourite Asian Comfort Foods

There is a particular kind of Australian childhood memory that involves a fish and chip shop, a paper bag and a deep-fried dim sim with a ge...

hacklink esim českoTrBetvpnfree books downloadzlibrarySahabet girişbetparkstreameastnon gamstopBetimselçuksportsgrandpashabet girişgrandpashabet girişdinamobetbetimStreamEastsohbet hattımarsbahistaraftarium24StreamEastholiganbetseo ajansıyurtdışı turseo danışmanlığıseo uzmanıgrandpashabet girişstreameastseo hizmetinakitbahisgrandpashabetjojobetviagra 100 mg fiyatjojobetjojobetcasibommy gift cardstreameastdeneme bonusu veren siteler 2026