Viw Magazine

Men's Weekly

.

  • Written by Dimitri Perrin, Senior Lecturer, Queensland University of Technology
The team used CRISPR on human embryos in a bid to render them resistant to HIV infection. But instead, they generated different mutations, about which we know nothing. SHUTTERSTOCK

More than a year ago, the world was shocked by Chinese biophysicist He Jiankui’s attempt to use CRISPR technology to modify human embryos and make them resistant to HIV, which led to the birth of twins Lulu and Nana.

Now, crucial details have been revealed in a recent release of excerpts from the study, which have triggered a series of concerns about how Lulu and Nana’s genome was modified.

How CRISPR works

CRISPR is a technique that allows scientists to make precise edits to any DNA by altering its sequence.

When using CRISPR, you may be trying to “knock out” a gene by rendering it inactive, or trying to achieve specific modifications, such as introducing or removing a desired piece of DNA.


Read more: What is CRISPR gene editing, and how does it work?


Gene editing with the CRISPR system relies on an association of two proteins. One of the proteins, called Cas9, is responsible for “cutting” the DNA. The other protein is a short RNA (ribonucleic acid) molecule which works as a “guide” that brings Cas9 to the position where it is supposed to cut.

The system also needs help from the cells being edited. DNA damage is frequent, so cells regularly have to repair the DNA lesions. The associated repair mechanisms are what introduce the deletions, insertions or modifications when performing gene editing.

How the genomes of Lulu and Nana were modified

Jiankui and his colleagues were targeting a gene called CCR5, which is necessary for the HIV virus to enter into white blood cells (lymphocytes) and infect our body.

One variant of CCR5, called CCR5 Δ32, is missing a particular string of 32 “letters” of DNA code. This variant naturally occurs in the human population, and results in a high level of resistance to the most common type of HIV virus.

Jankui’s team wanted to recreate this mutation using CRISPR on human embryos, in a bid to render them resistant to HIV infection. But this did not go as planned, and there are several ways they may have failed.

First, despite claiming in the abstract of their unpublished article that they reproduced the human CCR5 mutation, in reality the team tried to modify CCR5 close to the Δ32 mutation.

As a result, they generated different mutations, of which the effects are unknown. It may or may not confer HIV resistance, and may or may not have other consequences.

Worryingly, they did not test any of this, and went ahead with implanting the embryos. This is unjustifiable.

The mosaic effect

A second source of errors could have been that the editing was not perfectly efficient. This means that not all cells in the embryos were necessarily edited.

When an organism has a mixture of edited and unedited cells, it is called a “mosaic”. While the available data are still limited, it seems that both Lulu and Nana are mosaic.

This makes it even less likely that the gene-edited babies would be resistant to HIV infection. The risk of mosaicism should have been another reason not to implant the embryos.


Read more: 'Designer' babies won't be common anytime soon – despite recent CRISPR twins


Moreover, editing can have unintended impacts elsewhere in the genome.

When designing a CRISPR experiment, you choose the “guide” RNA so that its sequence is unique to the gene you are targeting. However, “off-target” cuts can still happen elsewhere in the genome, at places that have a similar sequence.

Jiankui and his team tested cells from the edited embryos, and reported only one off-target modification. However, that testing required sampling the cells, which were therefore no longer part of the embryos - which continued developing.

Thus, the remaining cells in the embryos had not been tested, and may have had different off-target modifications.

This is not the team’s fault, as there will always be limitations in detecting off-target and mosaicism, and we can only get a partial picture.

However, that partial picture should have made them pause.

A bad idea to begin

Above, we have described several risks associated with the modifications made on the embryos, which could be passed on to future generations.

Embryo editing is only ethically justifiable in cases where the benefits clearly outweigh the risks.

Technical issues aside, Jiankui’s team did not even address an unmet medical need.

While the twins’ father was HIV-positive, there is already a well-established way to prevent an HIV-positive father from infecting embryos. This “sperm washing” method was actually used by the team.

The only benefit of the attempted gene modification, if proven, would have been a reduced risk of HIV infection for the twins later in life.

But there are safer existing ways to control the risk of infection, such as condoms and mandatory testing of blood donations.

Implications for gene editing as a field

Gene editing has endless applications. It can be used to make plants such as the Cavendish banana more resistant to devastating diseases. It can play an important role in the adaptation to climate change.

In health, we are already seeing promising results with the editing of somatic cells (that is, non-heritable modifications of the patient’s own cells) in beta thalassemia and sickle cell disease.

However, we are just not ready for human embryo editing. Our techniques are not mature enough, and no case has been made for a widespread need that other techniques, such as preimplantation genetic testing, could not address.


Read more: Experts call for halt to CRISPR editing that allows gene changes to pass on to children


There is also much work still needed on governance. There have been individual calls for a moratorium on embryo editing, and expert panels from the World Health Organisation to UNESCO.

Yet, no consensus has emerged.

It is important these discussions move in unison to a second phase, where other stakeholders, such as patient groups, are more broadly consulted (and informed). Engagement with the public is also crucial.

Dimitri Perrin has received funding from the Australian Research Council (ARC), the Australian-French Association for Innovation and Research (AFRAN), and the Advance Queensland programme.

Gaetan Burgio receives funding from the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC), the Australian Research Council (ARC), the National Collaborative Research Infrastructure Strategy (NCRIS) via the Australian Phenomics Network (APN) ,Universities Australia and the Natural Science Foundation in China (NSFC).

Authors: Dimitri Perrin, Senior Lecturer, Queensland University of Technology

Read more http://theconversation.com/chinas-failed-gene-edited-baby-experiment-proves-were-not-ready-for-human-embryo-modification-128454

Sydney Gets Fired Up: Fireball Whisky Launches ‘Motel Fireball Inn’

The number one shot in Australia (and the USA) is turning up the heat!  Fireball Whisky is bringing the party to Sydney with the launch...

Why Headless CMS Is Essential for Global B2B Sales Enablement

B2B selling is more global, digital and complex than ever. B2B buyers want accurate, timely and needs-based information no matter where th...

Top Tips for Successfully Completing Training and Passing Driving Tests

Learning to drive can feel exciting and a little overwhelming at the same time. Whether you’re preparing for your very first driving test ...

Why Location Still Rules in Real Estate

When people talk about real estate, the phrase location, location, location always comes up. It might sound like a cliché, but it’s still...

The Ultimate Guide to Renting: Landlord and Tenant Rights

Renting a property can be a smooth and rewarding experience when both landlords and tenants understand their rights and responsibilities. Cl...

The Pros and Cons of Renting vs. Owning a Home

Deciding between owning and renting a home is a huge financial choice a lot of people have to deal with in their lifetime. While homeownersh...

Innovative Ways to Showcase Your Products and Services Effectively

You don’t have to be in these waters to know that marketing has always been a game of attention. Attention is expensive, even more than go...

How to Choose the Right Real Estate Agent for You

Whether you’re buying or selling a property, having a real estate agent on your side can be a game-changer. They know the ins and outs of ...

Finding True Connection in the Rush of Modern Life

Life in major cities is full of opportunities, yet many residents find themselves feeling disconnected and isolated. Despite being surrounde...

Finding Balance: Fun, Safety, and Connection in Modern Nightlife

Modern nightlife has evolved into more than just dancing and music—it’s a cultural space where people seek entertainment, connection, an...

Essential Skills and Tips for First-Time Volunteers Abroad

So, you have decided to embark on a jubilant adventure of volunteering abroad? Congrats, you are in for a real treat! Not only that, but who...

Essential Considerations When Choosing a Family Home

Finding the right home for your family is one of the biggest and most important decisions you'll ever make. It's about more than just a buil...

Considerations When Renovating or Expanding Your Property

Renovating or expanding your property can be an exciting journey, offering the opportunity to tailor your home or investment to meet evolvin...

Elevating Your Social Life: Experiences Beyond the Ordinary

In a world where so much of our daily routine feels predictable, people are increasingly searching for experiences that add meaning to life...

Essential Gardening Accessories for a More Comfortable Outdoor Lifestyle

Gardening should be fun and relaxing, not a chore. Having the right things with you can make a huge difference. This guide will show you sim...

Best Practices for Managing High-Volume Material Movement in Industrial Settings

If there is one thing that is the backbone of a large industry, that’s undoubtedly the ideal management of material movement. For any high...

8 Best Things to Do Near Ballarat, VIC

Ballarat isn’t just a city with a gold rush past—it’s a hub of adventure, history, nature, and amazing local experiences. Whether youâ...

Different Approach Proves Better Results in Addiction Counselling

Addiction is one of the biggest issues for relationships. It not only puts strain on the one struggling, but the people around them too. E...

5 Timber Decking Mistakes That Could Cost You Thousands

Dreaming of relaxing on your brand-new deck, soaking up the Aussie sunshine? A timber deck can be a fantastic addition to any home, creati...

7 Ways Disability Services Can Transform Lives

Imagine a life where you feel empowered, supported, and truly connected to your community. For individuals living with disabilities, this ...